# Gordon Smith on Pluribus Grenade: AI Debate, Carol's Demons, and That Sprouts Set Piece

> Pluribus: "Grenade" shows how to ask questions, lead with character pain, and keep scope honest. Give foes a code, cut bloat, and let viewers do the last 10%.

- Type: AI news
- Page: https://completeaitraining.com/news/gordon-smith-on-pluribus-grenade-ai-debate-carols-demons/
- Published: 2025-11-18
- Updated: 2025-11-18
- Author: Jeroen Erne
- Jobs: Writers
- Reading time: 3 min

### What Pluribus: "Grenade" Can Teach Working Writers About Story, Scale, and Staying Vague (On Purpose)

Note: spoilers ahead for Pluribus episode three, "Grenade."

Gordon Smith's path is a case study in how to build a career from the inside: office PA on Breaking Bad, assistant to Vince Gilligan, writers' assistant, staff writer on Better Call Saul, then a decorated run as writer-director. Now he's a writer-director-EP on Pluribus and the mind behind episode three, "Grenade."

For writers, this episode and Smith's process offer a handful of practical reminders: theme without lectures, clarity within massive scope, and a character-first engine that doesn't need a neat slogan.

#### 1) Don't write a thesis. Write a question.

Viewers are reading Pluribus as a take on AI, political division, addiction, even the cost of celebrity. Smith doesn't swat any of it down. He actively keeps space open. The point isn't a single metaphor-it's tension.

- Let multiple readings coexist. It keeps the story alive.
- Avoid one-to-one metaphors ("the monster is trauma"). That flattens TV.
- Build scenes that force disagreement in the room. The debate writes the drama.

#### 2) Character pain is the engine-don't sand it down

Carol's alcohol use isn't a plot accessory. It's a pattern. The Xanax-with-vodka moment reads as habit, not stunt. That nuance makes her choices scarier and more honest.

- Write coping mechanisms as routines, not one-offs.
- Let consequences compound. Don't rescue your character from themselves.
- Make "peace" tempting but complicated-the Joined offer that, and it's unsettling.

#### 3) Antagonists aren't mustache-twirlers-give them a code

The Joined caused near a billion deaths. Yet they're not simple villains. They'd give Carol weapons out of "love," but they have lines they won't cross. That ambiguity lets the audience argue culpability-especially when Carol's rage becomes lethal.

- Define the moral boundaries of your adversary. What will they do? What won't they do?
- Let the protagonist's emotions create real danger. That's agency with weight.
- Shift sympathy without preaching. Put your thumb on the scale, then step back.

#### 4) Big premise, bigger limits-write to what you can show

The Sprouts sequence looks huge because it's focused. A working grocery store was emptied, refilled, stitched with VFX, and coordinated across locations. Many "cool shots" were cut because they didn't improve the story-to-cost ratio.

- Ask: does this beat change anything? If not, cut it.
- Never reference an amazing set piece you can't show. It cheapens the world.
- Scale by specificity: one strong visual can carry the weight of ten.

#### 5) Timelines are story tools, not trivia

Pluribus uses a countdown/count-up to anchor viewers around the event and Carol's position relative to it. It's less about date stamps and more about rhythm.

- Use time markers to manage tension, not to show off continuity.
- Keep the audience oriented so they can focus on character.

#### 6) Blank canvas ≠ easy mode

Smith notes that building outside the Bad/Saul timeline was freeing, but it demanded heavier lifting up front. Casting tweaks and new information reshaped episode three midstream.

- Expect the early episodes to be the hardest. You're defining rules and feel.
- Stay flexible as production realities collide with story intent.

#### 7) How writers actually move up

Smith didn't assume a spot on Pluribus. He kept irons in the fire, said yes to a mini room, then took on more directing than expected. Proximity plus usefulness created luck.

- Don't bank on automatic invites. Keep options alive.
- Be the person who can answer the question today-not next week.
- Help steer the room. Seniority is often earned by handling the messy middle.

#### 8) Easter eggs are seasoning, not story

Small nods (FionaCom, Wayfarer) exist, but they're not an invitation to map universes. The team avoids anything that turns the show into IP algebra.

- Use callbacks to reward attention, not to carry the narrative.
- If an Easter egg steals focus, cut it.

#### 9) Practical checklist you can apply this week

- Rewrite three "statement" lines as questions that spark disagreement.
- Pick one character habit and make it a repeated choice with consequences.
- Trim one set piece by half. Keep the beat, lose the bloat.
- Add a simple time anchor to one episode or chapter to guide the reader.
- Define your antagonist's hard "no." Write a scene that tempts it.

#### Why this matters

Pluribus works because it refuses to be about one thing. It lets the audience do the last 10% of the work. That's the space where obsession starts-where your show lives in someone's head overnight.

#### Further exploration

- [AI tools for copywriting: a curated overview](https://completeaitraining.com/ai-tools/10b-ai-tools-for-copywriting/) (know the tools you're critiquing-or using-so your take lands).

---

This is the Markdown form of https://completeaitraining.com/news/gordon-smith-on-pluribus-grenade-ai-debate-carols-demons/. The whole site is mapped at https://completeaitraining.com/llms.txt.
