Design agencies have long subsidized the startup ecosystem by taking a chance on scrappy founders with interesting ideas. That quiet arrangement is breaking down as AI-generated briefs flood inboxes, making it nearly impossible for creatives to spot the founders worth betting on.
Daniel Hinde, founder of London agency Greatergood® Brands, said the nature of startup briefs has transformed in the last year. "It's gone from 'we're a startup and we only have X amount of money' to briefs that were clearly never written by the founder at all," he said. "They've been generated by an AI in a matter of seconds, and bulk sent to every agency sitting at the top of a Google search."
The mismatch AI creates
AI-written briefs follow a template that doesn't account for company size. A founder feeds product details into a chatbot, and it generates a document based on what its training data says a brief should contain. The result is a request for services that a one-person startup neither needs nor can afford.
"They're completely over-egged," Hinde said. "They'll ask for a full strategic proposal covering brand architecture, brand design, brand toolkit, packaging, retail strategy, go-to-market launch strategy, a website, a content plan, for a company that is genuinely one person and a £14.99 subscription to an AI model." He added that a founder at that stage doesn't need a fraction of those deliverables yet, and often can't afford even one element - but the AI doesn't know that.
Why agencies stopped taking the risk
Small design agencies used to discount their rates for founders who showed genuine thought in their approach. A personal brief signaled that someone had sat down and wrestled with what their business needed. That signal is now gone. Hinde estimates that nearly 90% of what lands from startups is impersonal and identical to what every other agency receives.
"When a brief used to land from a scrappy founder, you could tell someone had actually sat and thought about their business," he said. "That's exactly the kind of project we'd take a chance on." Now, with AI-generated requests asking for ten times the scope a startup needs, agencies can't distinguish which founders are serious. Many respond with quotes priced at corporate-client levels - or don't respond at all.
The irony is sharp. Founders use AI to save time and reach more agencies, but the impersonality of the output repels the very creatives who might have championed their project. The best agencies are selective about clients, and a bulk-sent, AI-written brief does nothing to sell a founder's vision. For creatives working in branding and design, understanding where AI fits - and where it doesn't - has become essential. AI for Creatives training increasingly covers not just how to use the tools, but when to avoid them entirely.
The response problem
Beyond the brief itself, AI models also dictate how agencies should respond. Hinde noted that each generated brief ends with a prescribed process and list of requirements for submitting a proposal. "The result is that serious agencies will simply send a quote at the same costing which we would send to a global client group, not a startup," he said. "It's either that, or we don't respond at all."
This dynamic pushes small founders further from the creative talent they need. Where an agency might once have taken a punt on a promising idea - building a portfolio piece or opening a door to a new category - the relationship now starts with a generic document and a corporate price tag.
Why this matters for creatives
For designers and brand strategists, the takeaway is practical. The signal that once helped you identify promising early-stage clients has degraded. Founders who write their own briefs - however rough - now stand out sharply against a sea of AI-generated documents. Hinde suggests the fastest way for a founder to make an impact on a creative agency is to simply write their own brief. For creatives, that means paying attention to briefs that show original thinking, however imperfect, and being willing to look past the polished-but-generic requests that AI produces. The technology that was supposed to connect founders and creatives faster is doing the opposite. Recognizing that shift is the first step to working around it.
Your membership also unlocks:
