A new study from Baylor University finds that artificial intelligence is reshaping how students learn, teachers instruct, and school leaders guide their schools, but the technology's greatest value lies in refocusing educators on distinctly human work.
Published in Frontiers in Education and led by William L. Sterrett, Ph.D., professor and chair of educational leadership at Baylor's Moody School of Education, the research draws on interviews with nine recipients of the National Association of Secondary School Principals' Digital Principal of the Year Award. The findings add to the growing conversation around AI for Education.
Making instruction personal
One of the study's central findings is AI's potential to help teachers tailor instruction to individual students. The researchers described a teacher who used AI to connect the Pythagorean theorem to baseball for a seventh-grade student struggling with math but passionate about the sport. Presenting the concept through the student's interest created a more engaging path to understanding.
The study also found that AI can make learning more immersive. A student used AI to create professional illustrations for a project about her family's immigration from Sudan, technology that enhanced her original concept without replacing her ideas or creative decisions. "AI should strengthen student learning, but not replace student thinking," Sterrett said.
Using AI for efficiency
Principals reported that teachers are using AI to prepare lessons, create assessments, differentiate instruction, and check whether students understand a concept. AI also reduces time spent drafting emails, planning lessons, and preparing materials, giving teachers more opportunities to work directly with students, the study found.
The principals did not believe AI had changed the fundamental purpose of school leadership. Building relationships, establishing a shared vision, and supporting strong teaching remain distinctly human responsibilities.
Balancing opportunity with caution
The study identified concerns about academic integrity and the possibility that overreliance on AI could diminish critical thinking and creativity. Schools may need to replace assignments that reward task completion with more authentic projects requiring analysis and original thought.
"If you want students to provide a thoughtful reflection on their own leadership journey, be very clear that the assignment is not for AI," Sterrett said. "You're preparing them to think deeply while also adding tools to their toolbox."
Innovation requires intentionality
Sterrett said principals can best model responsible AI use, while also providing professional development and involving their school communities in establishing expectations. Resources such as the AI Learning Path for School Principals can support educational leaders in this work. The researchers also noted that effective adoption requires attention to ethics, privacy, academic integrity, and relationships.
"The fears and hesitations with AI are less about the technology innovation, but rather what happens if we stop investing in human judgment, relationships, and thoughtful school leadership," Sterrett, a former school principal, said. "The future of schools will be shaped less by artificial intelligence itself than by what has always been most important-the quality of teachers, the relationships that occur, and the leadership that makes this possible."
Why this matters for education professionals
The study's central message is that AI is not a passing fad or a standalone tech initiative. It is a leadership issue that demands intentional modeling, professional growth, and a clear-eyed focus on protecting the human core of schooling. For teachers and principals, the practical path forward involves using AI to handle routine tasks so they can invest more time in the relationships and instructional decisions no algorithm can replicate. The research concludes that AI's greatest promise is not replacing educators but helping them concentrate on creating meaningful learning experiences.
Your membership also unlocks:
