Los Angeles Unified School District has blocked students from accessing generative AI on district-issued devices while it develops new rules for the technology. The restriction, which took effect this school year but drew little attention until this week, applies across all grade levels and marks a reversal from the district's previous policy that allowed students 13 and older to use approved AI tools after completing digital citizenship training.
The move has won praise from some parent advocates but raised concerns among education researchers and even some school board members about how students will learn to navigate AI if they cannot use it in school. The district said its generative AI committee will develop recommendations for student guardrails and bring them to the school board for consideration at the end of the school year.
A quiet policy shift
At the inaugural meeting of LAUSD's Generative AI Ad Hoc Committee on Wednesday, Interim Chief Information Officer Douglas Le said the district uses its firewall and Lightspeed web-filtering software to block categories of online content on student devices, including AI. The restriction applies both to standalone AI services and to AI features embedded within Google Workspace applications, an LAUSD spokesperson confirmed Thursday.
The restriction surprised even some members of the school board. Board member Kelly Gonez said she had believed the district was still operating under last year's policy and urged officials to make the new restrictions clearer to students, families, and educators. Board member Nick Melvoin said he was uncomfortable that the board had not explicitly approved the change and that it had not been widely publicized.
"It seems like, one, folks aren't aware of the policy with regards to restrictions, and two, if the policy is 'we're not going to allow students to use generative AI for the meantime,' then we should publicize that," Melvoin said, adding that the change "didn't really come from the board."
Teachers continue to have access to generative AI for their own work. The district said educators receive professional development on using the technology for tasks including instructional planning, developing lessons, and differentiating instruction. The district did not answer questions about who made the decision to impose the restriction, whether board members were notified before it took effect, or what criteria would eventually allow student access to resume.
Equity and access concerns
The restriction can follow students onto personal devices if they are logged into their district accounts, Le said. A student seeking to access a tool such as ChatGPT outside those controls would generally need to use a personal device and a non-district account. Melvoin raised a potential equity concern: students with personal computers or phones may continue using generative AI at home while classmates who rely on district devices cannot.
Stephen Aguilar, an associate professor of education at the University of Southern California who studies educational technology and generative AI, said broad restrictions can create problems. "It can encourage sort of an equity gap in terms of accessing different types of AI platforms," Aguilar said. He added that older students, in particular, need opportunities to learn how to assess AI-generated material because they are likely to encounter the technology in college and the workplace.
"Ideally that's what schools do," Aguilar said. "It's a safe space for students to try things and fail with the guidance of a teacher."
Can you teach AI literacy without AI?
Parent advocates who pushed for the restriction argue that students can learn to critically understand AI without using it. Lila Byock, an LAUSD parent and founder of Schools Beyond Screens, said her organization had been calling for a temporary moratorium on student-facing generative AI until the district's committee could review the research and recommend safeguards. She arrived at Wednesday's meeting expecting to reiterate that demand, only to learn the district had already imposed one.
Byock said restricting student access should not mean avoiding the subject of AI. Instead, she said schools should teach students how the technology is built, how training data is used, how generated information can mislead users, and what economic, environmental, and social interests may shape the tools. "We have to remember that teenagers are also children," Byock said.
Aguilar offered a different view. He said the effect of AI can vary significantly depending on the student, the classroom, and the specific tool. One student might use it to avoid doing difficult thinking, while another might use the same technology to create a study guide or deepen understanding of a difficult concept. Students ultimately need experience evaluating the technology itself, he said, particularly as they get older.
The district said it is continuing to train educators in the responsible use of generative AI, but did not describe what AI for Education literacy instruction for students will look like during the moratorium. The tension is particularly pronounced as LAUSD says it wants students to become AI-literate even while direct access is restricted.
Why this matters for educators
LAUSD's decision reflects a tension that teachers and administrators across the country are navigating: how to prepare students for a world shaped by generative AI while managing concerns about data privacy, academic integrity, and developmental readiness. The district's approach - restricting student access while training teachers - places the burden of AI literacy instruction on educators who may themselves still be learning the technology. For teachers seeking practical guidance on integrating these tools responsibly, resources like AI for Teachers can help bridge the gap between policy restrictions and the professional development needed to eventually guide students. The district's committee recommendations, expected at the end of the school year, will offer a clearer picture of what student AI use might look like - and what support educators will need to make it work.
Your membership also unlocks:
