Pinellas County Schools uses an AI-powered reading tutor called Amira with students in kindergarten through third grade, but some teachers say the program misidentifies correct and incorrect reading often enough that they question whether it belongs in the classroom.
The district has students use Amira for 30 to 40 minutes each week. The program listens to children read aloud, analyzes their speech, and gives them feedback on what to work on. It also serves as one of Florida's approved alternative assessments for "good cause promotions," meaning third graders who fail the state's FAST test can still move to fourth grade if they pass Amira's assessments.
Teachers report accuracy problems
Tracey McConnell, the new president of the Pinellas Classroom Teachers Association, spent more than 20 years teaching at Pinellas Central Elementary School before taking the role. She said she was initially excited about Amira but grew concerned after watching students use it.
"There were a lot of times that you would have kids reading words that were right but the computer was marking them wrong or vice versa, the kid would be reading words that were wrong that the computer was marking right so I didn't feel it was very accurate," she said.
McConnell said the accuracy issues cut both ways, and she worries about what happens when a flawed assessment influences whether a student advances a grade level.
District defends the program
Pinellas County school officials said in a statement that "Amira has been extremely responsive to any concerns and ideas provided to enhance programming."
McConnell disagrees with that assessment. "We need to back off this technology. There's no reason for kids as young as kindergarten, first, second grade to be doing stuff that has things with AI in it. That's too much," she said.
Neighboring districts have already pulled back on classroom screen time. Hillsborough and Pasco County Schools both cut back on screen time this school year. Pasco used Amira at only one school and dropped it before implementing its screen time initiative.
For now, Amira remains one of the tools Pinellas County Schools uses to support and assess student reading. Spectrum Bay News 9 reached out to Amira Learning for comment but did not receive a response.
Why this matters for educators
The dispute in Pinellas County is a concrete example of a problem teachers across Florida will face as AI assessment tools become more common: the software has to be accurate enough to make high-stakes decisions, and the people using it daily need a way to flag problems when it isn't. Teachers who want to evaluate tools like Amira before adopting them can start with training that covers how these systems work and where they tend to fail. Resources like AI for Teachers and AI for Primary School Teachers offer practical grounding in what these programs can and cannot do, which is useful context when a vendor's promotional video meets a classroom of real readers.
Your membership also unlocks:
