Americans and Canadians agree: retraining beats other AI job-loss fixes
Across party lines, adults in the U.S. and Canada converge on one clear answer to AI-driven disruption: invest in workplace retraining and reskilling. A multiyear survey of 6,000 people tested reactions to economic shocks from AI adoption versus offshoring, then asked which policies should follow. Retraining ranked first, regulatory oversight second, and expanded safety nets third.
For public officials, that's a mandate. People want help staying employable, not just bigger benefits after the fact. The message is simple: make training the default response to automation risk.
What the study surfaced
- Retraining and reskilling are the top bipartisan choices to address AI-related job loss.
- Regulatory oversight draws broad support but lags behind training.
- Safety nets matter, yet people prefer policies that keep them working and earning.
- Two mindsets drive policy preferences: "complementers" think AI boosts skills and wages; "substituters" expect AI to replace people and push wages down.
Those mindsets split on specifics. Complementers lean into education, reskilling, and social insurance. Substituters are more open to immigration limits and "robot taxes" that penalize companies for replacing workers.
Where to focus retraining dollars
Not every sector is equally exposed. Health care, skilled trades, management, and emergency services face less near-term automation than legal services and media. Policy should match exposure by occupation, not broad industry labels.
Training that works tends to be short, applied, and tied to real jobs. Think apprenticeships, co-ops, employer boot camps, and stackable certificates that move people into roles with hiring demand.
A practical policy menu for government leaders
- Fund outcomes, not seat time: Pay providers based on job placement, earnings gains, and retention at 6-12 months.
- Target by exposure: Map roles most affected by AI and prioritize those for rapid reskilling vouchers.
- Make employers co-invest: Offer matching grants for companies that run on-the-job upskilling and guarantee interviews or internal placement.
- Apprenticeships at scale: Expand paid pathways in high-demand fields, not just the trades. See the U.S. model for program standards and templates: apprenticeship.gov.
- Microcredentials that stack: Back short programs that add up to degrees. Require portability across institutions and states.
- Procurement with teeth: In AI-related contracts, require vendor-funded worker training and human-in-the-loop job redesign.
- Public sector first: Reskill your own workforce in data analysis, AI literacy, and process automation. Make curricula open to local employers.
- Local labor-market fit: Tie programs to real postings and wage data from regional employers and workforce boards.
- Safeguards without gridlock: Pair training with clear rules on privacy, bias testing, and transparency for AI used in hiring and public services.
- Measure and publish: Track enrollment, completion, cost per placement, and wage lift. Shut down what doesn't move the numbers.
Answers to the common questions you'll get
- "Does retraining mean teaching AI tools or steering people to safer jobs?" Both. Offer AI skills for current roles and pathways into less-exposed occupations. Let data guide which option pays better for each worker.
- "Do these programs work?" Results vary, but the better-designed ones raise earnings for displaced workers moving into new occupations-especially when tied to employer demand and paid experience.
- "Will politics stall this?" The support base is unusually broad. Training clears partisan filters in a way taxes and bans rarely do.
Quick wins you can launch this quarter
- Set a 12-month target for retraining placements in occupations with high posting volumes and mid-wage growth.
- Offer rapid grants to community colleges for 12-20 week programs co-designed with local employers.
- Issue RFPs that require vendors to cross-train public employees on any AI systems they deploy.
- Provide $2,000-$5,000 worker vouchers for approved microcredentials that include a job interview commitment.
Resources
- U.S. Registered Apprenticeship programs for templates, funding options, and compliance guides.
- Curated AI course paths by job function to seed catalogs for public-sector and vendor upskilling.
Bottom line
People are asking for a straightforward deal: help me learn what's next so I can keep working. Retraining and reskilling deliver on that, and the public is already on board. If you lead a government team, this is the policy with the least political friction and the clearest path to results-skills in, jobs out.
Your membership also unlocks:
