Viewpoint: Agentic AI Is Coming to Insurance - Much Faster Than You Think
Most teams now use AI to shave time off repetitive work. The next leap is agentic AI: autonomous systems that plan, decide, and learn while staying inside guardrails you set. After ITC Vegas, it's clear this isn't theoretical. It's being built across the value chain - from distribution to claims.
How Agentic AI Works - And Where It Helps Today
Agentic AI runs on the same core tech as generative AI, but adds step-by-step reasoning. You give it an objective; it maps the tasks, executes, and iterates. You can keep a human in the loop at key checkpoints or let it run within constraints.
Data quality is the make-or-break. With a clean, verified repository, an agent can scope a campaign, generate creative, launch across channels, and route qualified leads. It can assess a client's needs and budget, compare policies against underwriting guidelines, and surface the best-fit product. Voice agents can even hold natural conversations with prospects.
Real examples in market now: producer agents that target, launch, and tune cross-channel campaigns with a click. Agents that prefill applications, triage first notice of loss, and chase documentation so adjusters and producers can stay on higher-value work.
What Stays Human
Producers typically slog through ~16 manual steps before a client meeting - list building, creative, social posts, emails, brochures, scheduling. Agentic AI can automate nearly all of that pre-meeting work.
But binding remains human. U.S. rules require a licensed professional to sell and close business. No regulator is going to "license" software to own the full cycle. The smart play is simple: let agents do the heavy lifting, then hand off to the licensed broker at the point of sale.
Risks You Must Manage
The risks mirror traditional AI: hallucinations, bias, regulatory exposure, and opacity. That's why you keep humans in the loop and design for traceability.
- Data: Use clean, comprehensive, verified data. Build lineage and access controls for all sources feeding your agents.
- Testing: Run scenario tests before launch. Add continuous monitoring with alerts for drift, broken tools, or malformed outputs.
- Privacy: Apply strict PII handling, encryption, and minimization. Be transparent with customers about when and how you use AI.
- Explainability: If agents inform underwriting, you'll need to show how you got the result and prove it isn't biased or misleading.
Helpful frameworks exist. See the NIST AI Risk Management Framework for practical controls and governance (NIST AI RMF). State-level rules are arriving too - for example, Colorado's governance and discrimination rules for AI use in insurance (Colorado DOI).
Treat It as a Productivity System, Not a Headcount Play
The hard part isn't the tech - it's change management. Agentic AI won't replace licensed roles; it will refocus them. Let agents grind through the repetitive steps so your people can handle judgment, relationships, advice, and bind.
A 90-Day Plan for Carriers, MGAs, and Agencies
- Pick 2-3 high-impact use cases: producer pre-sale workflows, FNOL intake and triage, document chase, subrogation flagging, renewals outreach, cross-sell campaigns.
- Stand up your data layer: connect core systems (policy, billing, claims, CRM), define golden records, add access controls and audit trails.
- Define human-in-the-loop: specify checkpoints (e.g., quote review, suitability check, pre-bind approval). Only licensed professionals close.
- Add guardrails: policy constraints, template libraries, retrieval over approved content, role-based permissions, rate/rule/form adherence.
- Test and monitor: red-team prompts, edge cases, fairness checks; track error rates, turnaround times, and exception volume with live alerts.
- Compliance pack: document model purpose, data sources, limitations, and decision logs; prepare on-demand explanations for underwriting use.
- Vendor and tools: run a 4-6 week pilot with clear SLAs (accuracy, time-to-complete, cost per task). Keep humans ready to intervene.
- Upskill your team: train producers and adjusters to review, correct, and supervise agent output - including prompts, quality checks, and approvals. If you need a quick path, see these options (Courses by job, AI automation certification).
- Change the workflow, not just the tool: update procedures, handoffs, and compensation mechanics so AI-assisted work is rewarded and adopted.
- Measure what matters: quote turnaround time, submission-to-bind conversion, NIGO rate, CAC per channel, claim cycle time, reopen rate, and QA findings.
Timeline and Competitive Pressure
Agentic AI is arriving on a 1-2 year horizon across distribution, servicing, and claims. The risk isn't trying - it's waiting while competitors cut cycle times and win share.
Start small, supervise tightly, and scale what proves safe and useful. The teams that pair agents with licensed expertise will set the pace.
Your membership also unlocks:
