AI Ads Now Match Human Creative - Here's the Playbook Creatives Can Use Today
A new large-scale study with researchers from Columbia University, Harvard University, Technical University of Munich, and Carnegie Mellon University looked at how generative AI stacks up against human-made ads on Taboola's platform. The dataset was massive: 500M+ impressions and 3M+ clicks across hundreds of thousands of live ads. The headline: AI ads perform on par with human creative-and sometimes better.
Raw numbers show a slight edge for AI: CTR 0.76% vs. 0.65% for human-made ads. After strict controls, performance was comparable. The kicker is where AI wins big: when it doesn't look like AI.
What Actually Drove Performance
- AI that looks human wins. AI-generated ads perceived as "not AI" achieved the highest engagement of all groups.
- Faces build trust. A large, clear human face was the strongest visual trust signal. AI creatives, following platform best practices and policy restrictions, actually used these cues more consistently than human teams.
- No tradeoff on conversions. AI visuals matched or improved CTR without hurting downstream conversion performance.
- Early adopters: food & drink and personal finance brands led the way in using AI creatives.
Creative Checklist: Make AI Feel Human
- Lead with a face. Prominent, well-lit, eye-contact when relevant. Avoid tiny, obscured, or overly stylized faces.
- Keep artifacts out. Fix hands, eyes, jewelry, and text overlays. Anything that "feels AI" kills trust.
- Use natural color and light. Realistic tones beat hyper-saturated gradients for performance.
- Simplify the frame. Single subject. Clear focal point. Minimal background noise.
- Match promise to preview. Visuals should align tightly with headline and landing page intent.
Copy That Converts With AI Visuals
- Be specific. Concrete outcomes (time saved, dollars kept, steps removed) beat vague claims.
- Front-load value. First 5-7 words should make the click feel obvious.
- Speak like a human. Short sentences. Everyday language. Avoid buzzwords and overclaims.
- One promise, one CTA. Don't stack competing angles in a single ad.
Rapid Test Plan (One Week Sprint)
- Day 1-2: Produce 6-8 AI variants with human faces (diverse age, gender, angle). Keep backgrounds simple.
- Day 3: Pair each visual with two headlines: one benefit-led, one curiosity-led. Keep body copy identical.
- Day 4-6: Run siblings within the same campaign/day to mirror the study's approach. Monitor CTR and CPC.
- Day 7: Kill anything with clear AI artifacts or low engagement. Scale winners; retest with micro-iterations (expression, crop, lighting).
Why This Works
People trust people. Faces communicate safety and social proof faster than any headline. AI is simply making it faster and cheaper to produce clean, on-brief visuals that hit these cues without creative fatigue.
As one researcher put it, the data finally moves past opinions. "By analyzing over 500 million impressions, we were able to move past the hype of GenAI and uncover its real impact in large scale settings," said Oded Netzer, Vice Dean for Research, Columbia Business School. "Our findings prove that when AI is used to enhance human cues-like the trust found in a human face-it doesn't just match human performance; it often sets a new ceiling for engagement."
Methodology (Why You Can Trust The Findings)
- Quasi-experimental "sibling ads." Matched AI and human creatives from the same advertiser, same campaign, same day.
- Controls held constant: advertiser identity, timing, audience targeting, and landing pages.
- Scale: hundreds of thousands of ads, 500M+ impressions, 3M+ clicks on Taboola's platform.
Practical Angles To Test Next
- Face vs. no face: Quantify how much the face drives CTR for your vertical.
- Crop and composition: Tight headshot vs. medium shot; center vs. rule-of-thirds.
- Expression: Micro-smile vs. neutral; eye contact vs. gaze off-camera.
- Authenticity cues: Realistic skin texture, natural lighting, minimal retouching.
- Compliance-friendly text: Short overlays, legible fonts, no misleading claims.
Bottom Line For Creatives
- AI can match human performance-and win-if it feels human.
- Faces are your strongest trust lever. Use them well.
- Production speed no longer costs you conversions.
- Your edge comes from taste, testing discipline, and consistent pruning of anything that "looks AI."
Want More AI-Creative Systems?
If you're building a repeatable workflow for ad production and testing, this curated list of tools can help streamline your stack: AI tools for copywriting.
Your membership also unlocks:
