Post-Pandemic Differences in Oral Reading Fluency Between Brazilian Public and Private School Students
Understanding gaps in academic achievement between public and private schools remains crucial for educators and policymakers. This study examines oral reading fluency among Brazilian elementary students in the years following the COVID-19 pandemic, revealing key differences that emerge early in schooling.
Key Findings
- Private school students outperformed public school peers in words read correctly per minute (WRCM) by 4th grade and in the percentage of correct words (PCW) by 3rd grade.
- Private schools showed advancement to 5th-grade WRCM levels already by 4th grade, a pattern absent in public schools.
- No significant differences were found between school types in average consecutive correct words (CCW) or average silence between sentences (SBS).
Why Oral Reading Fluency Matters
Reading fluency is more than speed; it reflects accuracy and the ability to read with expression. Fluency bridges word recognition and comprehension, essential for academic success. Monitoring fluency helps identify students needing support and evaluates reading interventions.
Two main fluency indicators are often used:
- Words Read Correctly per Minute (WRCM): Measures reading speed and accuracy.
- Percentage of Correct Words (PCW): Reflects overall accuracy by comparing correct versus incorrect words.
This study also examined:
- Average Consecutive Correct Words (CCW): Indicates the ability to maintain error-free reading stretches, linked to prosody and rhythm.
- Average Silence Between Sentences (SBS): Measures pauses that can reflect reading rhythm and breath control.
Methodology Overview
The study included 1,296 students from 2nd to 5th grade, spanning public and private schools across 28 cities in Brazil. Students recorded their oral reading using an online platform, and audio was transcribed with an AI language model specialized in Brazilian Portuguese. This approach ensured objective, consistent evaluation of fluency metrics.
Statistical analysis employed linear mixed models to compare performance across school types and grades, accounting for individual school variability.
Interpreting the Results
The private school segment showed clear advantages in reading fluency speed (WRCM) by 4th grade and reading accuracy (PCW) by 3rd grade. Notably, private students achieved 5th-grade fluency benchmarks a year earlier than public school peers.
There were no significant differences in CCW or SBS, suggesting prosodic features and reading rhythm were similar across school types. This might indicate that while private schools help students read faster and more accurately, reading expression develops similarly in both groups.
Interestingly, the public school group showed a dip in CCW performance from 2nd to 3rd grade, hinting at challenges in maintaining fluency during this transition.
Context and Implications
These disparities align with international findings showing early reading fluency gaps linked to socioeconomic factors. The pandemic likely exacerbated these gaps, especially given unequal access to remote learning resources in public schools.
Early grades are critical for establishing reading skills. The shift from phonological decoding (sounding out words) to lexical recognition (instant word recognition) typically occurs between 3rd and 5th grades. Supporting students during this phase is vital for long-term literacy success.
Investing in targeted reading interventions and resources for public schools could help close these gaps. Regular fluency assessments, especially using AI-assisted tools, offer scalable, objective ways to monitor progress and tailor instruction.
Why AI-Assisted Reading Assessment Matters
Artificial intelligence streamlines oral reading assessments by providing fast, unbiased transcription and scoring. This reduces educator workload and enhances consistency in evaluating fluency metrics like WRCM and PCW.
Such tools can be integrated into school routines, giving teachers real-time insights into student progress and highlighting areas needing support.
Takeaway for Educators
- Early monitoring of oral reading fluency can identify achievement gaps between public and private school students.
- Focus on improving reading speed and accuracy in early grades, especially around 3rd and 4th grades, to support fluency development.
- Consider adopting AI-powered assessment tools to efficiently track and address student reading challenges.
- Recognize the importance of consistent reading practice and literacy support during and after disruptions like the COVID-19 pandemic.
Effective literacy development requires timely, precise evaluation and intervention. Leveraging AI technologies alongside instructional strategies offers a promising approach to support all learners in achieving reading fluency.
For those interested in exploring AI tools that can aid education professionals, resources are available at Complete AI Training.
Your membership also unlocks:
