Stocks Are Surging. Is This an AI-Fueled Bubble-and Should You Hold More Cash?
Indexes are setting new highs in 2025. What's unusual is how expensive stocks look against earnings. The S&P 500's cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings (CAPE) ratio sits near 39.65-levels last seen at the peak of the dot-com frenzy. It also spiked before 1929, a reminder that valuation risk is real.
Leaders are sounding cautious. The Fed Chair has said equities look "fairly highly valued," and a major bank CEO warned that many assets appear to be entering bubble territory. AI-heavy giants have powered much of the run: the "Magnificent Seven" gained roughly 698% from 2015 to 2024, versus 178% for the S&P 500. If there's a bubble, those names likely inflated it.
Should You Hoard Cash Right Now?
Money market fund assets hit a record ~$7.7 trillion in September, helped by attractive yields. That trend tells you investors are nervous-and that cash finally pays something again. But going all cash is a risky bet on timing, not a strategy.
The Problem With Market Timing
To time a bubble, you must be right twice: when to sell, and when to buy back. Peaks don't announce themselves, and bottoms are only clear in hindsight. In 2008, buying "the dip" on the way down often missed the true bottom. Most people end up missing gains and compounding stress.
A Practical Cash Strategy (Without Guessing Tops)
- Set your cash runway: Workers: 6-12 months of essential expenses. Retirees: 1-3 years of planned withdrawals in cash, T-bills, or short-term bond funds to reduce sequence-of-returns risk.
- Park cash intelligently: Compare high-yield savings, money markets, and 3-12 month T-bills. See Treasury bill basics at TreasuryDirect.
- Keep a target allocation: Define your equity/bond/cash mix and rebalance on a schedule or at set bands (for example, ±5%). This forces "sell high, buy low" without guesswork.
- Automate buying on weakness: Use ongoing contributions and dollar-cost averaging. If markets drop sharply, consider raising your 401(k)/IRA contribution by 1-2% to scoop up discounted shares.
- Pre-commit buy-the-dip rules: For example, add X% to equities for each additional 5-10% market decline-up to a cap. Write it down. Follow it.
- Avoid all-or-nothing moves: Maintain core diversified exposure across sectors, not just AI leaders. Add quality and cash-flow strength to balance narrative risk.
- Mind taxes and location: Place income-heavy and high-turnover funds in tax-advantaged accounts when possible. Use tax-loss harvesting to offset gains.
What to Watch if You're Worried About a Bubble
- Valuations: Track CAPE and forward P/E versus history. For a primer on CAPE, see this overview.
- Market breadth: Are a few mega-caps masking broader weakness?
- Earnings vs. price: Watch earnings growth and revisions, not just headlines.
- Rates and liquidity: Falling or rising rate paths can reprice risk quickly.
- Cash flows: Sustained inflows to money markets can signal caution-and dry powder.
Younger Savers vs. Near-Retirees
Younger investors: Stay mostly invested. Hold a modest cash sleeve (for example, 5-10%) to pounce on pullbacks and to cover emergencies without selling stock at bad prices.
Near-retirees and retirees: Prioritize a multi-year cash/T-bill buffer to fund withdrawals through a bear market. This protects your portfolio from selling low and gives equities time to recover.
AI Hype vs. Real Value
AI enthusiasm is driving multiples. Separate excitement from cash flows, margins, and adoption timelines. If you work in finance and want to judge real ROI, strengthen your fluency with practical tools and use cases-start here: AI tools for finance.
Bottom Line
Don't hoard cash. Hold enough cash. Build a deliberate cash reserve, keep a disciplined allocation, and use rules to deploy capital when prices fall. Let process-not fear-dictate your moves.
Your membership also unlocks:
