AI-Driven Algorithm Volatility Is Forcing Marketers Back to First Principles, Says NYC Strategist Augustus Kirby
Automation scaled marketing. Frequent algorithm shifts broke many teams' ability to steer it.
Across search, social, and programmatic, updates now swing performance week to week. Agencies are stuck in reactive mode, while in-house teams are pushed to tie every click to revenue. The tension exposes a larger gap: AI is being rolled out faster than most organizations can govern.
The message from New York: AI needs human judgment
"AI has changed the mechanics of marketing, but it has not replaced the need for judgment," said Augustus Kirby from his New York City office. "When algorithms shift overnight, the brands that win aren't chasing every update. They have a clear strategy, strong data foundations, and people who know when to step in."
That starts with accepting a simple truth: fully automated systems will optimize to the metrics you give them, even if those metrics quietly drain margin or weaken your brand over time.
Automated bidding is efficient-until it isn't
AI-led bidding now adjusts budgets, delivery, and audiences in real time. It often looks great on dashboards. But without guardrails, it can over-optimize for cheap conversions, expand into low-quality placements, or bias toward short-term wins that hurt LTV and trust.
- Set a revenue "north star": CAC to LTV ratio, MER, and incrementality-not just CPA or ROAS.
- Codify brand safety and audience exclusions. Enforce consent and data minimization.
- Audit weekly beyond surface KPIs: incrementality tests, holdouts, placement quality, creative fatigue.
- Stress-test assumptions: conversion windows, seasonality, bid caps, budget pacing. Run structured A/B and geo splits.
- Create escalation triggers and a kill switch for spend anomalies or brand risk.
- Document interventions and hypotheses so learning compounds across quarters.
A practical human-in-the-loop framework
Kirby promotes a simple model: let AI handle scale and speed while experts set the goals, monitor the output, and correct course.
- Set up: Clean tracking, offline conversion imports, standardized naming, consent management, and a single source of truth for revenue and LTV.
- Operate: AI runs day to day. Marketers review signals, design tests, and enforce guardrails. Creative teams feed diverse, on-brand assets to reduce model bias.
- Review: Monthly business reviews tie spend to revenue, margin, and LTV. Keep a living playbook of interventions and patterns by channel.
Skills and confidence are now the bottleneck
A recent Forrester finding shows only 37% of employees feel confident adapting AI systems in their roles. In complex marketing setups-multiple platforms, markets, and regulations-that lack of confidence slows progress and increases risk.
- Run enablement programs that explain how models make decisions and where they fail.
- Teach prompt patterns, QA checklists, and failure modes for bidding, targeting, and creative.
- Stand up an internal "AI council" across paid, analytics, brand, legal, and data engineering.
If your team can't explain why the system acted a certain way, you don't control your marketing.
Protect brand trust while you optimize
As platforms tune for engagement and cost, it's easy to drift into tactics that clash with your values or your customers' expectations. In a market like NYC-skeptical, informed, and vocal-missteps get expensive fast.
- Review audience segmentation and sentiment models for bias and drift.
- Set hard lines on claims, placements, and data use. Log exceptions and approvals.
- Tie optimization to outcomes that matter beyond this month's CPA: retention, referrals, and net revenue.
For structured risk practices, see the NIST AI Risk Management Framework here, and for paid media automation mechanics, review Google's Smart Bidding overview here.
What high-performing teams do differently
- Start with strategy and measurement, then apply automation. Not the other way around.
- Track incrementality and LTV, not just in-platform metrics.
- Keep a rolling test roadmap with clear hypotheses and decision rules.
- Use cross-channel attribution that includes offline impact and time-to-convert.
- Set vendor governance: data contracts, model disclosures, and audit rights.
- Prepare contingency plans for major algorithm updates and policy shifts.
Upskill your team without the guesswork
If capability is the constraint, build it. For structured learning paths and certifications focused on marketing use cases, explore AI Certification for Marketing Specialists and curated AI courses by job.
The bottom line
Frequent algorithm changes aren't going away. The advantage will belong to teams that pair clean data and clear strategy with hands-on oversight. Treat AI as a capable partner-one that performs best with firm goals, frequent reviews, and humans willing to intervene.
Learn more about this approach at augustus-kirby.com.
Your membership also unlocks:
