AI Stocks Stumble as Valuations Face a Reality Check
Investors are pressing pause on sky-high AI valuations. On Tuesday, shares of Oracle, Nvidia, AMD, and Amazon dropped sharply as the market questioned whether profits can catch up to the hype.
Nvidia fell just under 4% and AMD slid nearly 3%. Palantir took the biggest hit, down over 9% despite a Q3 beat. The common thread: stretched price-to-earnings multiples. Palantir trades at roughly 200x forward earnings, a level that invites tough questions about sustained revenue growth and cash generation.
What's Driving the Pullback
After a six-month run that pushed the S&P 500 up more than 20%, the index slipped nearly 2% over the past five days. That cooling mirrors a simple concern: soaring AI capex with revenues that haven't caught up.
"Profits are good, but I think investors are starting to ask themselves, based on the pace of capex investments from some of these key Big Tech companies, 'Are you going to see the profit growth over the next year to justify the levels of capex?'" said Ameriprise's Anthony Saglimbene. Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon warned of a potential 10% to 20% market drawdown in the next 12 to 24 months.
Meta's Signal: Big Spend Meets Skepticism
Meta said it will boost its already heavy AI spend this year. Investors pushed back: the stock fell more than 11% on Thursday and is down over 16% in five days. The message is clear-capex without crisp monetization is getting discounted.
High-Profile Shorts Add Fuel
Michael Burry disclosed short positions against Palantir and Nvidia. Whether he's early or right is the open question. Palantir CEO Alex Karp fired back: "The two companies he's shorting are the ones making all the money, which is super weird… The idea that chips and ontology is what you want to short is bats*** crazy."
Valuation Check: What to Watch
In markets built on expectation, the multiple is the message. High P/E isn't a problem if earnings growth accelerates and turns into free cash flow. The problem is when capex outruns monetization.
- P/E and forward P/E vs. realistic growth. If growth slows, multiples compress. See a primer on the P/E ratio.
- Capex-to-sales and capex-to-GM. Rising capex with flat margins signals pressure.
- Free cash flow after capex. Pay attention to cash generation, not just adjusted earnings.
- ROIC vs. WACC. Can AI investments clear the cost of capital?
- Unit economics of AI products. Pricing power, usage growth, and churn will tell you if demand is real.
- Supply constraints. GPU availability and costs can pinch margins longer than expected.
Positioning Ideas for Investors
- Trim exposure to names with extreme multiples, negative FCF, and unclear AI monetization.
- Favor firms with proven AI revenue streams, rising FCF, and disciplined capex disclosures.
- Use a barbell: profitable compounders on one side, selectively priced cyclicals or cash-rich defensives on the other.
- Consider hedges into earnings and macro catalysts if your book is tech-heavy.
- Watch guidance language on AI revenue timing, margin impact, and capex cadence.
For Operators and Finance Teams
- Set ROI gates on AI spend. Tie budgets to shipped features, user adoption, and net new revenue.
- Pilot before scale. Measure payback periods and kill projects that miss thresholds.
- Track GPU and cloud costs in real time. Reprice, throttle, or redesign workloads when unit costs spike.
- Reinvest where AI directly lifts gross margin or reduces opex with verified savings.
Bottom Line
The AI story isn't broken. It's just moving from promise to proof. With multiples stretched and capex heavy, the market wants clean evidence that earnings-and cash-will follow. If that proof lags, expect more chop.
If you're assessing practical AI use cases and ROI in finance, this curated list can help surface tools worth testing: AI tools for finance.
Your membership also unlocks:
