AI Jitters Hammer Commercial Real Estate Brokers - What It Means for Finance Pros
Commercial real estate brokers are selling off for a second straight day. CBRE sank more than 12% intraday and closed nearly 9% lower on Thursday - a move Oppenheimer notes has only been worse during Covid and the global financial crisis.
Peers followed: Jones Lang LaSalle fell 7.6%, SL Green Realty dropped about 5%, and both Newmark and BXP slid more than 4%. Hudson Pacific Properties shed nearly 4%.
Why the Rotation Is Happening
Investors are dumping high-fee, labor-heavy models seen as vulnerable to AI. As Jade Rahmani at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods put it, markets are rotating out of businesses that could be disrupted by AI-driven disintermediation.
The pattern has been consistent this year: first software, then financials, and now real estate. Flows have moved toward defensive sectors like staples.
AI Shockwaves Beyond Real Estate
The fear isn't isolated. Trucking and logistics stocks tumbled after an AI freight scaling tool surfaced: C.H. Robinson fell around 20%, RXO 25%, and J.B. Hunt more than 6%.
Earlier, software names were hit after a top-tier AI model appeared capable of replacing pricey licenses for coding and legal work. Wealth managers dipped after a new AI-powered tax planning tool promised results in minutes.
Structural Pressure Was Already There
CRE has been stressed for a while - higher rates and remote/hybrid work have weighed on office demand. AI is now viewed as a possible accelerant.
A viral essay argued entry-level, white-collar jobs will be gutted by AI, with an impact bigger than Covid. Elon Musk went further, suggesting office towers once packed with workers could be replaced by AI-driven firms. His point: an entire building of human "computers" can now fit in a laptop spreadsheet.
Fears May Be Running Ahead of Reality
Not everyone buys the doom. Rahmani notes that while tech has long threatened to cut out intermediaries, the immediate risk to complex deal-making looks overstated - the long-term effect is still "wait-and-see."
CBRE just reported a solid quarter: core EPS of $2.73 beat estimates, and full-year guidance of $7.30-$7.60 sits around consensus. CEO Bob Sulentic pushed back on disruption fears, saying CBRE uses AI to assist brokers - not replace them - and that transactions rely on strategic, creative thinking and deep relationships. "We haven't seen any evidence to the contrary."
Barclays' Brendan Lynch kept overweight ratings on CBRE and Newmark, calling the sell-off inconsistent with earnings profiles. He noted AI has been a net job creator so far and argued CRE servicers could benefit from new revenue and cost efficiencies.
Still, there's a catch. Macquarie's Thierry Wizman warned that companies slow to adopt AI - or overly reliant on costly human-led workflows - may face existential pressure as outcome-driven AI agents take over end-to-end processes.
What to Watch Next
Markets are scanning for the next domino. If the pattern holds, any sector with high labor intensity, heavy fee structures, and repeatable workflows is in the crosshairs. The key question: how long does panic selling outpace fundamentals?
- Rates and office utilization still matter more than headlines in CRE cash flows.
- AI adoption speed and margin impact will separate winners from laggards.
- Near-term volatility could diverge sharply from operational performance.
Practical Moves for Finance and CRE Leaders
- Audit workflow exposure: map processes that are repeatable, rules-based, and high-fee. Prioritize AI augmentation there first.
- Protect the moat: emphasize complex, multi-stakeholder deals where relationships, local knowledge, and bespoke structuring dominate.
- Quantify savings: target 10-30% cost takeout across research, underwriting prep, comps, and marketing via AI tooling.
- Upskill now: train teams on prompt fluency, data hygiene, and agent orchestration to compress cycle times.
- Client messaging: show how AI improves speed, transparency, and options - without sacrificing judgment.
- Vendor strategy: test a short list of AI platforms with clear ROI and data controls; avoid tool sprawl.
- Stress test margins: model fee compression and throughput gains to see if you can hold or grow EBIT with AI in the loop.
Context That Helps
For a macro lens on AI and jobs, see independent research on labor exposure and policy responses from the IMF.
If you're building an AI plan for finance or real estate operations, these resources can speed up evaluation and training:
- Curated AI tools for finance - scan options by function and use case.
- AI Automation Certification - structure team upskilling and real workflows.
Bottom Line
AI fear is dictating flows, but earnings and execution still decide long-term winners. If your model is high-touch and repeatable, expect pressure. If you can pair relationship-driven deal work with AI-enabled speed and cost, there's upside on the other side of this sell-off.
Your membership also unlocks:
