AI is coming for your creative team first, marketers say
Key stat: Creative and content production tops the martech areas marketers expect AI to disrupt most, cited by 27% of UK and North America respondents, per a November 2025 StackAdapt and Ascend2 survey.
Budgets are already moving. 83% of marketing leaders say they would cut agency spend if they could fully automate content creation, according to Typeface's Signal Report. Among teams that have adopted AI agents, 73% have already reduced agency content creation costs.
The trade-off: quality risk. Nearly 40% of digital video ads will be AI-generated this year, and 57% of marketing agency leaders already cite AI content oversaturation as a top concern (IAB).
What this means for creative and marketing leaders
- Creative ops face the earliest and hardest pressure-briefing, drafting, resizing, versioning, and ad copy are getting automated first.
- Agency scopes are shifting from production volume to strategy, concepting, and QA. Expect fewer hands on execution and more accountability on outcomes.
- Quality becomes the moat: unique brand voice, distinctive concepts, and strong editorial judgment separate you from same-same AI output.
How to use the chart with your leadership team
- Frame disruption: Show that content production is the top target for AI-and why your team needs process, tooling, and guardrails now.
- Benchmark investments: Compare your current AI budget and pilots to the areas peers expect to change most.
- Prioritize pilots: Pick 2-3 workflows in creative ops with high volume and clear success metrics (ad variations, social cutdowns, product copy refresh).
- Plan agency realignment: Shift spend from repetitive production to concept development, brand stewardship, and testing.
90-day plan to capture gains without burning your brand
- Audit your pipeline: Map every creative task from brief to publish. Tag each as automate, augment, or keep human-only (for now).
- Stand up an AI workbench: Central prompts, reusable templates, and brand voice rules in one place. Assign owners and approval thresholds.
- Redesign QA: Require human edit passes on high-visibility assets; enforce fact checks, claims review, and compliance checks pre-flight.
- A/B everything: Benchmark AI-assisted creative against a human baseline for CTR, CVR, view-through, and cost per asset.
- Reset agency scopes: Move repetitive production out; hold agencies to ideas, storyboards, and performance lift.
Quality guardrails that actually work
- Voice and visual rules: Tone, banned phrases, style references, and examples of "on brand" vs. "off brand."
- Source scrutiny: Verify data, citations, and rights for any AI-suggested claims, visuals, or audio.
- Originality checks: Run similarity scans; vary prompts, structures, and references to avoid sameness.
- Watermark and label where required: Keep internal traceability for generated assets and training data.
Budget shifts to consider now
- Reinvest production savings into concept testing, audience insights, and higher-velocity creative experiments.
- Fund first-party data enrichment and feedback loops so models learn from your performance, not generic internet output.
- Allocate a QA line item-editorial, legal, brand safety-proportional to the share of AI-generated assets.
Metrics your CFO and CCO will both respect
- Cost per asset and time to first draft (baseline vs. AI-assisted).
- Revision cycles per asset and percent approved on first pass.
- Share of AI-generated creative by channel and format.
- Performance delta vs. human-only baselines (CTR, CVR, ROAS, brand lift).
- Quality flags: factual errors, legal/compliance issues, off-brand voice, and negative sentiment.
Reality check on saturation
If 40% of digital video ads go AI this year and most leaders worry about sameness, your edge is differentiation, not volume. Build creative concepts from proprietary insights, customer language, and original brand IP-then let AI scale versions, sizes, and copy options around that core idea.
Where to go deeper
Methodology
Data is from the December 2025 StackAdapt report "The State of Programmatic Advertising 2026." Ascend2 surveyed 484 senior marketing professionals from the US, Canada, and the UK between October 24 and November 12, 2025. Respondents were 64% brand-side and 36% agency leaders, all manager level or above, at organizations with annual marketing budgets of $5 million USD or more.
Related reports
- Ad Agency Trends 2026 (EMARKETER subscription required)
- Digital Advertising Trends to Watch in 2026 (EMARKETER subscription required)
We prepared this article with the assistance of generative AI tools and stand behind its accuracy, quality, and originality.
Your membership also unlocks:
