AI and commercial insurance broking: existential threat or strategic opportunity?
AI has lit up the insurance headlines again. A consumer app announced an AI quoting tool and broker stocks took a hit. It's a familiar pattern: fear of disintermediation spikes, predictions of the broker's demise resurface, and commercial lines get lumped in with personal lines noise.
Here's the bottom line: for commercial insurance, AI is a strategic opportunity dressed up as a threat. It won't erase the broker. It will expose who operates with real leverage and who runs on admin and inertia.
Did the market overreact?
We've seen this movie. Aggregators squeezed personal lines margins. Big tech flirted with insurance distribution. Insurtechs promised to flatten the chain. Brokers adapted and survived.
Commercial is different. Complexity, bespoke coverage, negotiation, claims advocacy and ongoing risk advice create real barriers to disintermediation. AI doesn't bulldoze those barriers; it mostly trims friction around them.
What AI in insurance actually does today
Most tools live at the front end: data capture, marketing, triage, quoting support, and workflow automation. Even when AI collects information or compares coverage, customers still flow back into traditional underwriting, placement and advisory paths.
Think aggregators as a reference point: great for transparency and speed, not a replacement for nuanced, relationship-driven broking.
Where disintermediation risk is real
Risk sits on a spectrum. Small commercial and commoditised personal lines move closer to self-serve. That's where AI can narrow the gap between buyer and carrier.
Mid-market, upper mid and enterprise risks are different. Risk discovery, coverage architecture, insurer engagement, negotiation and claims strategy still decide outcomes. That work is defensible-and AI makes it stronger.
The real opportunity: productivity
Commercial broking runs on unstructured data and documents. That's exactly where generative AI shines. Done right, it reduces admin drag and creates leverage for producers and account teams.
- Claims and loss history analysis with cleaner summaries and patterns surfaced fast.
- Faster drafting of proposals, renewal packs and side-by-side coverage comparisons.
- Meeting prep and real-time support: account history, key exposures, likely objections, next best questions.
- Enterprise knowledge management: turning tribal knowledge into searchable, reusable assets.
AI augments people; it doesn't replace them. It frees senior talent to spend more time on risk thinking, proposition design and negotiation-the work clients actually pay for.
Why brokers start from a position of strength
Brokers own advantages that AI-native entrants can't spin up overnight: trusted client relationships, proprietary data across cycles, institutional memory on coverage and claims, and market access built deal by deal.
Combine those assets with AI and the moat gets wider. You increase coverage quality, speed and insight without hiring linearly.
Governance and guardrails
AI will influence advice; accountability stays human. In regulated settings, errors create financial, legal and reputational risk. That demands auditability, documented review, and human-in-the-loop controls.
If you need a reference framework for risk controls and oversight, see the NIST AI Risk Management Framework (NIST AI RMF).
Avoiding commoditisation
Generic outputs flatten perceived value. If every broker feeds the same prompts into the same public models, advice starts to look identical.
The fix: train on your proprietary data, embed AI inside your workflows, and align use cases to a clear value proposition. Your edge isn't the model-it's your data, judgment and client context.
What great broking will look like
Productivity up. Cycle times down. Better coverage architecture, cleaner documentation, tighter claims narratives, sharper insurer engagement.
Client expectations will rise with the experience. The firms that combine expert humans with AI-assisted insight will stand out. Excellence gets louder. Mediocrity has nowhere to hide.
A practical action plan for brokers
- Map friction: document-heavy, repeatable tasks in placement, servicing and claims. Prioritise three high-yield use cases.
- Stand up a secure AI workspace: data controls, logging, and role-based permissions from day one.
- Embed human review: define thresholds for when producers, technical brokers or legal must sign off.
- Train on your assets: loss runs, endorsements, coverage opinions, placement memos and claims outcomes. Keep a clean feedback loop.
- Pilot with one vertical and one team. Measure cycle time, quote-to-bind, coverage quality markers and client satisfaction.
- Industrialise what works. Build playbooks, prompts, templates and reusable components into your core workflow.
Threat or opportunity?
AI isn't an existential threat to commercial broking-it's an inflection point. It rewrites the operating model, not the need for expert advisors.
Move early, invest deliberately, and put AI at the core of how you sell, place and serve. If you don't, the competitor that does will feel like they hired two extra teams without adding headcount.
Further resources
Your membership also unlocks:
