Why AI Won't Replace the Super Bowl Ad, But Can Transform How It's Made
Could AI replace a multi-million dollar Super Bowl production? It's the question echoing from edit bays to boardrooms. Here's the short take: AI won't replace the human craft behind a tentpole ad - but it absolutely can change how you make one.
The teams that win are using AI as a collaborator. They're cutting time-to-first-frame, exploring bolder options in pre-production, and building smarter post pipelines. They're not gambling their brand on a one-click spot.
The industry pulse: from live-action to AI
At CICLOPE, the conversation shifted from "if" to "how." Producers and directors are already using AI to speed up treatments, previs, and post. The confusion often lives higher up: "Can a $3M Super Bowl spot be made for $50K?" Technically yes - if you're okay trading cultural impact for novelty.
AI has been in post for years. GenAI expands the toolkit, but it doesn't erase the craft. Even AI-led hero work from global brands still runs through 10-12 week timelines because quality control, rights, and brand integrity still matter.
What actually works: the hybrid model
The most effective path is a hybrid: live-action for emotional truth, CGI for scale and polish, AI for speed and visualization. Think of the NFL's season opener films - live people, real direction, top-tier post, plus AI-enabled elements stitched into a cohesive story. That's the model that holds up under Super Bowl-level scrutiny.
AI is useful from script through finish: faster concepting, richer director's treatments, sharper previs, smarter versioning, and targeted personalization. Not a prompt-to-finish shortcut - a multiplier on your team's talent.
A strategic approach by content tier
One method won't serve every format. Treat your mix like a system, not a single bet.
- Craft - Tentpole brand campaigns (e.g., Super Bowl): Lead with human performance, direction, and story. Use AI to plan, visualize, and streamline - not to replace the heart of the piece.
- Content Engine - Social and e-commerce: Lean into AI for speed, scale, and variant testing. Let automation carry routine production so your team can focus on concept and narrative.
- Maker - Influencer and UGC: Keep it raw and real. This space rewards human quirks. Use AI sparingly (captions, cleanup, light assist) without sanding off authenticity.
A one-size-fits-all workflow risks bland outputs and brand drag. Precision beats volume.
Where AI adds real value in production
- Ideation sprints: Rapid boards, mood builds, and narrative options to align faster.
- Previs/storyboards: Block complex scenes before you set foot on location.
- Look-dev: Style frames, lighting studies, and product beauty tests.
- VFX and animation: Plate cleanup, roto, background augmentation, and realistic simulations.
- Audio polish: Dialogue cleanup, sound design scaffolding, multilingual scratch VO.
- Localization/versioning: Faster language, offer, and format variants with guardrails.
- Content ops: Asset tracking, QC aids, and automated compliance checks.
Risks and guardrails you can't ignore
- Rights and likeness: Lock usage terms, consent, and model/voice rights for any synthetic work.
- Data governance: Keep brand assets out of public models; use secure environments.
- Bias and brand safety: Audit outputs; set escalation paths for sensitive content.
- Disclosure: Align on when and how to disclose AI use based on legal and platform policy.
- Continuity and QC: Enforce visual/story consistency; train your eye for AI "tells."
Metrics that matter to the CFO
Stop debating if AI "saves millions" on a tentpole. Measure where it compounds value.
- Time to alignment: Days from brief to greenlit concept.
- Cycle time: Treatment → board → previs → shoot plan.
- Version velocity: How fast you ship quality variants by market and offer.
- Hit rate: Percentage of concepts that clear testing and stakeholder review.
- Personalization ROI: Incremental lift from targeted creative versus single-master.
- Asset reuse: How often shots, rigs, or looks transfer across campaigns.
A simple playbook for your next tentpole
- Pre-brief: Define the emotional beat, brand truth, and hard lines (what must be human).
- Hybrid board: Map each shot to live-action, CGI, or AI assist. Decide why - not just how.
- Look tests: Build style frames and quick previs to lock tone before you spend.
- Shoot for story: Cast for nuance; direct for moments audiences feel.
- Post with intention: Use AI for cleanup, augmentation, and smart versioning - keep a human gate at every phase.
- Legal and rights: Paper every likeness, dataset, and usage window early.
- Personalize smartly: Localize messaging, not meaning. Protect the core story.
- Debrief: Capture time saved, creative wins, and where AI added or subtracted quality.
The bottom line
Big-stage ads win on emotion, performance, timing, and taste. AI helps you get there faster and with more options, but it won't replace the human spark that makes culture pause. Treat AI as a skilled collaborator, not the showrunner, and you'll ship work that earns attention - on game day and after.
Want a structured path to upskill your team on practical AI for creative work? Explore our courses by job or scan the latest AI courses.
Photography credit: Dave Adamson at Unsplash
References: NFL, CICLOPE Festival
Credits
Thought Leaders in association with Partners in Crime
Your membership also unlocks:
