AI investment is massive. Returns aren't-yet. Here's how leaders fix it
AI spend is soaring. Gartner projects nearly $1.5 trillion through 2025, yet value remains elusive. One stat sums it up: most pilots fail to scale or pay off. The 2025 Cisco AI Readiness Index shows just 13% of companies see consistent, measurable returns - and 99% of those winners have a clear strategy, a change mindset, and formal employee enablement.
The lesson is simple: the technology isn't the bottleneck. Leadership clarity and strategic alignment are. AI pays when you use it to create capacity and fuel growth, not just cut costs.
Set the goal: capacity creation, not headcount reduction
Most pilots die because the target was wrong. If you measure AI by "expense line down," you'll optimize yourself into a corner. Measure by "capacity up" - more customer interactions handled, faster cycle times, higher quality per person - and returns become visible and defensible.
Take contact centers. AI can coach agents, route calls, summarize notes, score quality, and forecast staffing. Many firms skip the hard work of defining the right KPIs and jump straight to staff cuts. Klarna tried that, customer scores dropped, and they had to rehire. That wasn't a tech failure. It was a leadership miss on planning and measurement.
Tech limits vs. leadership gaps
Yes, integration and data are hard. But most ROI misses come from poor governance and weak business cases. Projects launched as "experiments" with no line-of-sight to a strategic outcome are easy to cancel and hard to measure.
Greg Shewmaker, CEO of r.Potential, puts it plainly: "Everyone's been racing to build more AI models, compute, and agents, but the real bottleneck to enterprise AI adoption isn't supply, it's that enterprises don't know where or how to use AI to do real work... If we don't get this right, the next wave of automation won't just reshape companies, it'll destabilize work itself."
That's the brief: stop treating AI as a lab toy. Treat it as workforce design. Align people and machines against real demand, and tie deployments to business outcomes.
The leadership model that works
- Outcome-first planning: Define one to three business outcomes worth real money (e.g., NPS +5, time-to-quote -40%, cash conversion +10%). Pick measurable capacity metrics that ladder into those outcomes.
- Use-case charter: For each initiative, write a one-page charter: strategic objective, current baseline, target lift, affected roles, model risks, data needed, rollout scope, sunset criteria.
- Work decomposition: Break roles into tasks. Automate the 60-80% that is repeatable. Redeploy people to the 20-40% that drives revenue, loyalty, and innovation.
- Runbooks and guardrails: Define decision rights, human-in-the-loop checkpoints, escalation paths, and audit logs. Ethics and compliance are operating constraints, not afterthoughts.
- Capability building: Stand up a formal enablement program for leaders and frontline teams. If you need structured paths by role, see this resource: AI courses by job.
- Value tracking: Weekly scorecard with a signed owner: capacity created, quality metrics, cycle-time deltas, error rates, and dollar impact. No value? Stop or rescope.
What to automate vs. what to elevate
- Automate: repetitive workflows, data extraction, summarization, categorization, routing, forecasting, low-risk recommendations, compliance checks.
- Elevate humans: exceptions, complex negotiations, high-stakes decisions, creative problem solving, customer empathy, cross-functional orchestration.
- Golden rule: If a task needs empathy, judgment, or context stitching across silos, keep a human in the loop. If it's repeatable and documentable, automate aggressively.
Contact center KPI stack (example)
- Capacity: handled contacts per hour per agent, self-service containment rate, first-contact resolution.
- Quality: NPS/CSAT, quality score variance, compliance adherence.
- Efficiency: average handle time, wrap time, schedule adherence, recontact rate.
- Financials: cost per resolved contact, save rate, cross-sell conversion.
Tie AI features to this stack. For example, auto-summarization should reduce wrap time and error rates; coaching should lift CSAT and first-contact resolution. If metrics don't move, the tool isn't delivering value or the process needs a redesign.
90-day execution plan
- Weeks 0-2: Pick two priority outcomes. Map one value stream end-to-end. Write use-case charters. Set baselines and the weekly scorecard.
- Weeks 3-6: Pilot with 1-2 teams. Ship the smallest deployable feature set. Instrument everything. Hold twice-weekly ops reviews.
- Weeks 7-12: Expand to adjacent teams. Lock runbooks and guardrails. Launch the enablement program. Publish a quarterly "capacity P&L" that shows where time and dollars were freed and where they were reinvested.
Governance that prevents rework
- Portfolio fit: Every AI project must map to a strategic priority; no orphan pilots.
- Data readiness: Named owners for data contracts, quality, lineage, and retention.
- Risk controls: Model evaluation, prompt security, PII handling, and red-team tests before scale.
- Change management: Clear role impacts, reskilling paths, and incentives tied to adoption.
Questions every board should ask
- Where, specifically, does AI create capacity in the next quarter? Show the baseline and target.
- What work are we stopping because of this deployment? How are we redeploying people to higher-value activities?
- Which metrics will move, by how much, and by when? Who signs the scorecard weekly?
- What are the failure criteria that trigger a pivot or shutdown?
- How are ethics, security, and compliance embedded in the runbook - not bolted on?
The takeaway
AI ROI is a leadership problem dressed up as a technology problem. The companies winning aren't chasing demos; they're building capacity and redeploying talent to the work that grows the business. Get clear on outcomes, deconstruct work, set guardrails, and measure value weekly.
If your organization needs a structured path to upskill roles by function, explore role-based AI training. For a view of what leading organizations are doing, see the Cisco AI Readiness Index.
Your membership also unlocks:
