Fighting for Writers’ Rights: Victoria Aveyard and Others Oppose Generative AI in Publishing
Authors today face more than just storytelling challenges. The rise of generative AI in publishing is sparking intense debates, with many writers viewing it as a direct threat to their creative work and income. Over 70 authors recently signed an open letter to publishers, urging them to protect authors’ rights against unregulated AI use. This letter, available on LitHub, captures the concerns of many creatives about AI’s role in the industry.
The divide between supporters and critics of AI in publishing is stark. Supporters often overlook how AI-generated content can replace genuine human creativity, while authors see it as a form of theft and devaluation of their craft. Amid this tension, it’s encouraging to witness authors uniting to defend the value of human-driven writing.
The Importance of Author Involvement
Authors are stepping out from behind the curtain, showing readers the faces behind their favorite books. This visibility helps readers understand why it matters that human creativity should not be replaced by machines. Connecting with the community strengthens the bond between writers and readers, creating a united front against AI exploitation.
Victoria Aveyard: A Leading Voice Against AI Misuse
Victoria Aveyard, known for her Red Queen and Realm Breaker series, has been outspoken about AI tools infringing on her intellectual property. She actively engages with fans on social media platforms like Threads, TikTok, and Instagram, using these channels to discuss both her work and the risks AI poses to writers.
A particularly troubling incident for Victoria involved her original characters appearing on Character AI, a platform where AI bots respond as fictional characters based on user descriptions. This happens without author permission or compensation, raising ethical concerns. While some defend these sites by comparing them to fanfiction, Victoria clarifies the difference: fanfiction is created with effort and passion and is not intended for profit. In contrast, AI-generated content repurposes authors’ work into products that compete in the market without crediting the original creators.
The Core Issue: AI as Uncompensated Recycling of Human Creativity
Victoria and many other authors argue that AI is not producing original content but remixing existing human work without consent. Large companies profit from this unregulated practice, ignoring the rights of the writers whose stories fuel these AI models.
One way Victoria protests is by sharing videos of herself manually editing her massive manuscripts, highlighting the value of hard work and craftsmanship. This stands in contrast to the AI-driven push for speed and convenience, which risks producing shallow, formulaic content.
Exploring the Debate: Victoria’s Podcast with Soman Chainani
Victoria recently co-launched a podcast called Plot Twist with Soman Chainani, author of The School For Good and Evil. The podcast addresses current publishing topics, including an episode titled “Would You Read a Book Generated by AI?” Here, both authors share differing views on AI’s role in literature—one more optimistic, the other more cautious—offering listeners a balanced look at this ongoing debate.
What’s Next for Authors and Readers?
It remains uncertain how much publishers will heed the open letter or implement protections for authors. However, the vocal resistance led by Victoria Aveyard and her peers is creating obstacles for unchecked AI adoption in publishing. Their advocacy focuses on influencing readers’ perspectives, encouraging them to support genuine authorship over AI-generated imitations.
Many readers have voiced their commitment to choosing books written by humans, recognizing the passion and effort behind authentic storytelling. For those who truly value reading, supporting real authors means rejecting AI-produced content that lacks soul and depth.
Readers Hold the Power
The future of publishing hinges on the choices readers make. If enough readers back authors by refusing to buy AI-generated works, publishers will see such books as risky investments rather than easy profits. Now is the moment for writers and readers to stand united and protect the integrity of the written word.
For writers looking to understand AI’s impact on creativity and publishing, resources like Complete AI Training offer courses that explore AI tools and their implications for various jobs, including writing. Staying informed equips authors to navigate these challenges more effectively and advocate for their rights.
Your membership also unlocks:
