Embedded vs. bolt-on: How insurers will pursue measurable results from AI in 2026
The noise around AI is loud, but results are what matter. Many carriers and MGAs tried bolt-on tools at the edges of legacy platforms and expected big wins. Most didn't get them. The real gains in 2026 will come from embedding AI into the core workflows that run the business.
The real opportunity is in the core, not the edges
Underwriting, quoting, claims, and compliance are where AI can carry the load and free experts to make better calls. Layering AI on top of a 10-to-15-year-old system rarely delivers the step-change you need. To get value, AI must be embedded directly into the workflow that manages the process, not parked beside it.
That requires control and adaptability. Teams on modern, agile digital platforms can iterate faster, test AI inside real processes, and switch out what doesn't work. Those trapped by rigid legacy stacks will struggle to move beyond demos and pilots.
A practical playbook for 2026
- Test-and-learn to drive real change
You don't need a massive budget. Start small, ship quickly, and collect feedback in days, not quarters. Kill "shiny tool" experiments that don't move core metrics, and double down where cycle time drops, accuracy improves, or leakage shrinks. - Protect the data; protect the foundation
AI is only as useful as the data behind it. Anchor on three fundamentals: provenance matters, preserve raw data, and keep humans in the loop. For guardrails and governance patterns, see the NIST AI Risk Management Framework (NIST AI RMF) and the NAIC guidance on AI use in insurance (NAIC AI resources). - Look for the learners; they'll fill roles that don't exist yet
AI will augment skilled professionals, not erase them. Expect roles like a senior AI underwriter overseeing a team of AI agents. Find the people who are curious, adaptable, and comfortable iterating with machines-then give them room to build. - Focus on high-impact workflows for sustained ROI
Prioritize broker submissions, automated underwriting, subrogation identification, and renewal risk management. Use AI agents to gather data, make recommendations, and trigger actions across systems-while keeping well-defined human checkpoints for oversight.
What embedding AI actually looks like
- Underwriting: AI pre-screens submissions, structures unstructured data, flags missing info, and proposes appetite and pricing guidance. Underwriters review exceptions and edge cases.
- Claims: Triage and routing based on severity and fraud likelihood, with AI drafting subrogation opportunities and recovery actions for adjuster approval.
- Compliance: Automated document checks, audit trails, and explainability summaries pushed to reviewers before filing or issuance.
- Renewals: Risk drift detection, exposure deltas, and AI-drafted negotiation points, all surfaced to account teams with rationale.
Make legacy workable while you modernize
You don't need to flip the whole stack at once. Wrap legacy with APIs, event streams, and queues so AI agents can read, write, and act without fragile screen-scraping. Start by instrumenting the process for observability-timestamps, decision reasons, exception codes-so you can measure impact and trace outcomes.
Choose platforms and partners that let you compose workflows, version models, and roll back fast. If a model drifts or a rule backfires, you should be able to revert within minutes, not weeks.
How to measure "measurable"
- Speed: Submission-to-quote time, FNOL-to-closure time, regulatory review turnaround.
- Quality: Loss ratio impact from better risk selection, leakage reduction, audit exceptions per 1,000 files.
- Adoption: % of workflows with AI assist enabled, human override rates, time saved per role.
- Control: Data provenance coverage, explainability availability, rollback time, and model/update approval SLAs.
2026: From pilots to production
This is the year AI moves from the margins into daily operations. Carriers and MGAs that embed AI in core workflows will see leaner processes, tighter controls, and a better customer experience. Those who stay at the edges will keep paying for tools that look impressive and deliver little.
If you're upskilling teams to lead these changes, a structured learning path helps. See curated options by role at Complete AI Training.
Your membership also unlocks:
