If Chatbots Can Replace Writers, It's Because We Made Writing Replaceable
Writers aren't losing to machines. We're losing to the templates we trained ourselves to use.
For years, we've optimized for predictable output: SEO blogs, listicles, cookie-cutter essays, and frictionless edits. Chatbots didn't create this taste for the average. They're just very good at serving it.
The uncomfortable truth
Much of commercial writing already reads like a photocopy of a photocopy. That's not an insult-it's an economic design. Standardization makes content cheaper to produce, faster to ship, and easier to monetize.
So when a tool shows up that can predict "the average answer," it eats the average work. That's what large language models do: they predict what an acceptable response looks like and generate it on command.
What AI replaces-and what it doesn't
AI is built for specification-driven writing: summarize, rephrase, outline, expand, clean up. It's brilliant at average-case outcomes. Most clients, most days, want exactly that.
But AI doesn't have a body. No stress hormones. No obsession. No grudge. No mortality. It can simulate voice; it can't live a life. Literature, essays, and criticism worth reading are anchored in a specific vantage point-time, place, upbringing, private fixations, and the scars you don't mention but still write around.
If you want language that feels lived-in rather than produced, you need glands, limits, and risk. Machines can write good sentences. Humans write from a nervous system.
Why readers still need humans
Writing isn't just packaging information; it's thinking in public. The value is in the struggle-the false starts, the edits you delete, the idea that breaks only after you stare at it for a week.
As Walter J. Ong argued, writing changes how we think, not just what we say. If you outsource the struggle, you outsource the insight.
Your moat as a writer
1) Be aggressively specific
- Write from place, profession, dialect, subculture, and body. Vague equals replaceable.
- Collect details only you would notice: smells, rhythms, nicknames, inside jokes, petty fears.
- Keep a private lexicon: words you overuse, phrases you invented, quirks you won't edit out.
2) Source material AI can't access
- Report in person. Walk the site. Call the grump no one else calls. Sit in the boring meeting.
- Mine diaries, voice notes, marginalia, failed drafts, and your search history.
- Write through your obsessions and grudges-don't sand them down.
3) Add productive friction
- Refuse the default template for your important work. Change structure, tense, or point of view.
- Give yourself constraints (1,000 words, no adjectives, only concrete nouns) to force originality.
- Edit for "pulse": where do you feel heat in the body? Keep that. Cut the smooth filler.
4) Move up the value chain
- Sell taste, not keystrokes: positioning, argument, editorial judgment, thesis design.
- Offer interviews-based ghostwriting, development edits, and narrative strategy. These hinge on trust and listening.
- Build direct channels: newsletter, small membership, or salon-style community.
Use AI for drudgery, not for voice
Let the machine carry the buckets so you can paint the wall. Keep your hands on the sentences that matter.
- Do delegate: transcripts, meeting notes, first-pass summaries, outline options, alt headlines, meta descriptions, style checks.
- Don't delegate: your thesis, your examples, your scenes, your transitions, your metaphors, your endings.
- Always verify quotes, facts, and names. Treat outputs as drafts, not truth.
If you want a vetted list of AI tools to offload boilerplate without dulling your voice, start here: AI tools for copywriting. For better prompts that keep your style intact: prompt engineering resources.
The money problem (and how to respond)
Technology doesn't kill income; ownership captures it. That was true in the mills; it's true online.
- Price on outcomes, not word count. Quote per project tied to business results where possible.
- Negotiate usage, exclusivity, and rights. Charge more for buyouts. Keep your byline when it helps your career.
- Diversify: one premium client, one recurring client, one personal project that builds equity.
Two-mode writing workflow
- Mode A: Product - standardized content that pays bills. Systematize it. Use AI to speed it up. Protect quality; don't overspend attention.
- Mode B: Encounter - the work only you can write. Slow, specific, embodied. No templates. Publish less, say more.
What to write next
Write the piece that would be worse if it were smoother. The essay that needs your history to make sense. The scene you're a little afraid to show your friends.
If chatbots can replace parts of your job, let them. Then use the time you win back to make something they can't average out-work with fingerprints, not polish.
The goal isn't to beat the machine at its game. It's to play a different game entirely, one where readers come to meet a mind, not a template.
Your membership also unlocks:
