Colorado Democrats back bill to gut landmark AI discrimination law
Colorado's top Democrats are backing legislation that would largely dismantle the state's 2024 AI discrimination law, replacing its core protections with weaker disclosure requirements. Senate Bill 26-189, introduced Friday, comes after months of closed-door negotiations and pressure from AI companies and the business community.
The original law, Senate Bill 24-205, was the first in the nation to regulate how AI systems make consequential decisions about employment, housing, healthcare, and insurance. It required companies to conduct risk assessments, take steps to prevent discrimination, and publish detailed information about how they use AI.
SB-189 would scrap those affirmative duties. Instead of upfront disclosure requirements, the new bill would require only a simple notice that automated decision-making technology is being used. Detailed information would only be provided if a consumer requests it within 30 days of receiving an adverse decision.
What changes under the new proposal
- Replaces "high-risk artificial intelligence systems" and "algorithmic discrimination" with a narrower definition: "automated decision-making technology"
- Removes requirements for risk assessments and reasonable steps to prevent discrimination
- Shifts from proactive disclosure to reactive disclosure on request
- Adds a 30-day window for consumers to request detailed information after an adverse outcome
- Requires "meaningful human review … to the extent commercially reasonable" only when requested
Senate Majority Leader Robert Rodriguez, a Denver Democrat who sponsored the original 2024 law, is now backing the revision. "If someone is denied housing or a job, loses their healthcare, or sees their insurance rates mysteriously skyrocket at the hands of automated technology, they deserve to know what criteria went into that decision," Rodriguez said in a statement.
The shift reflects intense opposition from AI companies and Colorado's business community since SB-205 passed in May 2024. Elon Musk's xAI and the U.S. Department of Justice sued to block the law, and Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser suspended enforcement last month.
How the compromise came together
Governor Jared Polis signed SB-205 but immediately expressed "reservations" about its potential to "tamper innovation and deter competition." The law was originally set to take effect in February 2026, but after negotiations broke down a year ago, state leaders delayed it to June.
In October 2025, Polis appointed an 18-member task force to revise the law. The group's meetings were not fully open to the public, and its structure resembled a proposal previously offered by the Colorado Chamber of Commerce. When the task force released its recommendations in March, Polis praised the group's "unanimous agreement on AI policy."
SB-189 closely mirrors that task force proposal. Senate President James Coleman, sponsoring the bill alongside Rodriguez, called it the result of "years of work to find the right policy framework."
Labor and progressive groups remain cautious
The People's Alliance for Responsible Technology, a coalition of progressive and labor groups, said Friday it was "cautiously optimistic" about the compromise. Dennis Dougherty, director of the Colorado AFL-CIO, said the group would monitor whether disclosure requirements adequately protect workers, patients, and consumers.
SB-189 will be heard first by the Senate Business, Labor and Technology Committee on Tuesday. The legislative session ends May 13.
For legal professionals, understanding these regulatory changes matters. AI for Legal professionals covers how these compliance frameworks affect contracts, liability, and corporate governance. Those in legal support roles may find the AI Learning Path for Paralegals useful for understanding AI regulation and its implications for legal research and document analysis.
Your membership also unlocks:
