Is the Take-Home Essay Dead, or Are We Starving Writing of Time?
More professors are throwing up their hands and calling the out-of-class essay obsolete. Not because students can't think, but because AI can now spit out clean prose faster than we can assign it.
Let's be honest: this isn't the same as students skimming SparkNotes instead of reading Bleak House. With AI built into everyday tools-word processors, grammar checkers, even note apps-the line between a student's words and the machine's polish gets blurry. That's not just a shortcut. It's a shift in authorship.
The real problem isn't AI. It's time.
Writing takes time-thinking, drafting, revising, being wrong, then making it right. Teaching writing takes time, too. And the practice required to develop strong voice and independent thought takes even more.
Moving everything into proctored exams or blue-book essays won't fix that. Most classes aren't built for sustained writing practice. Fifty- to eighty-minute blocks can't replace the hours it takes to work from messy idea to tight draft.
A Practical Fix: Writing Labs
We need the writing equivalent of science labs-required, credit-bearing sessions where students write weekly under human guidance. No outsourcing. No disappearing into AI prompts. Just focused work, from conception to completion, with coaching and peer feedback built in.
Call it a lab, a workshop, or a practicum. The label doesn't matter. The point is simple: writing can't be taught without writing. And writing won't happen at the depth it requires without protected time and a clear container.
What a Writing Lab Looks Like
- Weekly blocks (2-3 hours) dedicated to drafting, revising, and reflection.
- AI-off windows for the core draft, with transparent guidelines on when AI can be used (e.g., outlining or line-editing after a human draft exists).
- Process checkpoints: proposal → outline → rough draft → revision plan → final.
- Peer review that targets ideas first, sentences second.
- Instructor coaching on choices: structure, argument, evidence, and tone.
- Short "revision sprints" to test fixes in real time.
Why This Matters (Even If You're a Professional Writer)
Writers aren't immune. AI makes it easy to skip the mental heavy lifting that builds voice, clarity, and judgment. If every draft starts machine-smooth, you lose the friction that teaches you how to think on the page.
The goal isn't to ban tools. It's to build a boundary: human-first thinking, then machine-assisted refinement. That order preserves your voice and your value.
The Scenic Route Rule
Shortcuts are addictive. So make the scenic route nonnegotiable for part of your process. That's where your original ideas form, your taste sharpens, and your style matures.
A Playbook You Can Use Right Now
- Block "lab time" weekly: 2-3 hours of AI-off deep work. Draft from scratch. No tabs, no summaries, no polish. Just you and the page.
- Define your AI zones: where it's allowed (idea mapping, proofing, formatting) and where it isn't (core drafting, argument building, voice decisions).
- Keep process artifacts: outlines, handwritten notes, failed starts. They're receipts of thinking and a library of raw material.
- Use versioning: V1 (messy human draft), V2 (structural revision), V3 (clarity), V4 (optional AI line-edit). Label each pass.
- Add peers: Trade drafts with 1-2 writers. Ask for notes on thesis, structure, and claims before sentence-level edits.
- Ship something weekly: a finished piece, a tightened section, or a pitch. Volume builds skill.
For Colleges, Programs, and Teams
- Reassert the value: Writing is thinking made visible and shared. That's the outcome to protect.
- Invest in faculty prep: Train instructors to teach writing with AI in the room-clear use policies, process-based assessment, and workshops on feedback.
- Make labs required: Attach weekly writing practicums to writing-heavy courses. Grade the process as well as the product.
- Assess what matters: Track drafts, revisions, and reflection. Reward growth in judgment and clarity, not just clean prose.
AI Isn't the Enemy. Passive Writing Is.
Tools should extend your ability, not erase your effort. Keep the human work where it counts-idea formation, structure, argument, and voice. Let tools clean at the end, not craft at the start.
If you want a curated way to work with AI without losing your voice, explore our resources for writers and content teams: AI tools for copywriting and prompt practices you can adapt to your workflow.
Bottom line
Don't bury the essay. Fix the time model. Give writers protected space to think, struggle, and refine-with real humans in the loop. That's how we keep the craft alive and the work honest.
Your membership also unlocks:
