At experiential agency Backlash, the Monday morning kickoff meeting once crackled with energy when a new brief landed. Now, a project often starts with the same deflating sentence: "The client has created an AI visual." Almost every week, a brand arrives with an AI-generated pop-up design in hand, already convinced it's the solution. The images look hyper-real - perfect finishes, stunning architecture, exactly the right location. But the work rarely answers the actual brief, and the creative energy in the room vanishes before the conversation even begins.
"An AI generated design is the conclusion of a process it never actually went through," the agency said. The concept hasn't been shaped by audience research, consumer behaviour, or the testing of multiple angles that might change behaviour, spark conversation, or drive sales. No creative thinking has happened. Yet clients present these images as the pop-up they want built.
When the wow factor ignores the real world
A global luxury beauty brand recently approached Backlash with an AI design for an outdoor shopping centre activation. It featured towering make-up compacts stacked seven metres high, forming a walk-through structure. The problem: UK health and safety regulations and venue requirements would never approve it. Even if it could be engineered, the concept ignored the client's budget and production timelines entirely. The AI had sidestepped all constraints. The agency then had to explain why the exciting idea wasn't feasible, a conversation that often makes them look like the ones taking the magic away.
The real value of a pop-up isn't the structure or the fabrication, the agency argues. It's concept development - the phase where commercial objectives are understood before any design begins. Questions like "Who are we trying to reach?" and "What behaviour are we trying to change?" drive that process. But brands are increasingly removing that step, arriving with a prompt-generated answer instead of a problem. The worry isn't that clients use AI tools - many agencies, including Backlash, use them to work smarter. The worry is that clients trust AI's first answer more than the expertise they're paying for.
The risk isn't to agencies, but to brands
AI is designed to predict the most likely answer based on everything that already exists. If brands start from the same moodboards, trained on the same imagery and prompted in similar ways, the work will begin to look like variations of one another. The chase for efficiency can erase the distinctiveness that makes a brand stand out. The most successful pop-ups, the agency said, disrupt through authenticity and emotional connection, not because a design looked impressive. "The best experiential campaigns have never been about the fastest idea, it's always been about creating the right one."
For creatives, the shift demands a sharper ability to guide clients back to fundamentals. Understanding the limitations of AI-generated concepts - and articulating why a prompt cannot replace the messy, human process of developing an original idea - becomes a core skill. Resources like AI for Creatives can help professionals build the literacy to push back when a client's AI output ignores practical or strategic realities. The real edge over the next decade will belong to those who know when to stop listening to the algorithm and lean into cultural insight and creative instinct.
Why this matters for creatives
The situation at Backlash is a preview of a broader pressure point. When clients mistake an AI-generated image for a finished concept, the creative's role is reframed as a deliverer of someone else's half-formed idea, not a strategic partner. The most valuable work - questioning the brief, exploring consumer behaviour, and inventing something that hasn't been seen before - gets compressed or skipped. For Design professionals, the takeaway is direct: the brief is still the starting point, and the ability to defend it, deconstruct flimsy AI concepts, and redirect the conversation toward what will actually work in the real world is what protects both the quality of the work and the role of the creative itself.
Your membership also unlocks:
