Fantasy Author Faces Backlash After AI Prompt Accidentally Left in Book
Fantasy author Lena McDonald has come under fire from readers after an AI-generated prompt was discovered in her novel Darkhollow Academy: Year 2. The book, part of the reverse harem romance genre, contained a visible AI note asking to rewrite a passage to mimic another author’s style. This slip-up has sparked criticism around the ethics and care involved in using AI for creative writing.
The Incident
In the third chapter of Darkhollow Academy: Year 2, readers found a prompt meant for AI editing left in plain sight. It read: “I’ve rewritten the passage to align more with J. Bree’s style, which features more tension, gritty undertones, and raw emotional subtext beneath the supernatural elements.” J. Bree is known for her bestselling fantasy and romance novels, and McDonald appeared to be using AI to imitate her voice.
The mistake was quickly caught by fans, who expressed disappointment and frustration. The publisher has since removed the prompt from the Amazon version of the book, but screenshots continue to circulate on social media.
Reader Reactions
- “That’s an instant ban from me,” wrote one reader.
- Another questioned, “What is the point of writing books if you aren't going to write them? Don’t people enjoy writing?”
- A third fan commented, “I don’t think she’s the only author doing it and I wish there was a way to tell. So many books lately have been changing author voice midway through.”
The incident has sparked a broader conversation about transparency and authenticity in writing, especially as AI tools become more accessible. Many writers and readers are concerned about the impact on originality and trust.
AI Use in Professional Settings Under Scrutiny
This is not the first time AI use has caused controversy in a professional context. Recently, lawyers representing My Pillow CEO Mike Lindell faced judicial reprimand after submitting a legal brief containing numerous AI-generated errors, including false citations and misquotes. District Judge Nina Wang ordered the attorneys to explain why sanctions should not be applied.
Such incidents highlight the risks of relying on AI without thorough review, especially in fields where accuracy and credibility are critical.
What Writers Should Take Away
For authors, this serves as a cautionary example. AI can be a useful tool for brainstorming or editing, but it requires careful oversight. Leaving AI-generated content unvetted or visible to readers can damage your reputation and reader trust.
Writers considering AI assistance should maintain control of their voice and ensure transparency where appropriate. Proper editing and thoughtful integration of AI can enhance productivity without sacrificing authenticity.
For those interested in learning how to work effectively with AI tools, resources like prompt engineering courses offer practical guidance on using AI responsibly.
Your membership also unlocks:
