The Crisis in Student Writing: Why We Must Fight for Reflection and Critical Thinking
For nearly a decade, I have coached high school students on crafting their college essays. Over the years, I’ve seen firsthand how writing transforms young minds, helping students reflect on their experiences and articulate their unique stories. Writing isn't just communication—it’s a tool to immortalize what makes each person distinct.
But recently, something has changed. The rise of AI tools like ChatGPT has shifted the landscape dramatically. This year, my students arrived with essays generated by AI, struggling to outline or write anything without its help. Many have never drafted a full essay on their own, and their critical thinking skills are showing the strain.
Why Writing Matters More Than Ever
Writing forces us to think deeply about who we are, what we value, and how we see the world. It develops reasoning and reflection—skills linked to critical thinking and future success. When students stop writing, they stop thinking at a higher level.
Though many educators are moving away from longer essays to group projects or presentations, these alternatives cannot replace the unique value writing offers. Only through writing can students wrestle with complex ideas and develop self-awareness.
The Impact of AI on Student Writing
Students who began high school after the public launch of ChatGPT in 2022 have had constant access to AI-generated writing help. The result? A generation that is less practiced in reflection and original thought.
Many students come to sessions with AI-written essays and seem lost when asked to outline or draft independently. This trend threatens the very skills that writing cultivates.
What Educators and Writers Must Consider
- Writing is essential for developing critical thinking and self-reflection.
- AI tools present a challenge but also a call to reaffirm the importance of original writing.
- Shifting away from writing assignments risks producing students who lack the capacity for deep thought.
For those of us who work with words, there’s a responsibility to advocate for writing as a discipline that shapes thinkers, not just communicators. Students deserve more than a future scripted by machines.
If you’re interested in how AI impacts writing skills and want strategies to adapt, explore courses on AI and writing techniques at Complete AI Training. Understanding how to integrate AI responsibly can help preserve the craft of writing while preparing for the realities of modern tools.
Ultimately, preserving the art of writing means preserving the ability to think critically. It’s time to recommit to teaching students how to write, reflect, and own their stories.
Your membership also unlocks:
