Don't Let AI Become Your Mentor
AI is fast, friendly, and always "proud of you." That's exactly why it's risky as your main source of career advice.
Recent studies say 41% of Gen Z trust AI more than human mentors, and half would rather ask a bot about work problems than a person. I get it. It's easier. But easy rarely builds a creative career that lasts.
Why AI Can't Replace a Mentor
Nat Maher, founder of Kerning the Gap, puts it plainly: generative tools are great scaffolding, but the real transformation is human. "As a mentor, you bring two valuable things you'll never get from a bot: empathy from shared experience, and challenge."
A proper mentor isn't just a cheerleader. They're a professional friend who's earned the right to push you, call out your blind spots, and hold you accountable to what you said you wanted.
AI can't read the room or sense what you're afraid to say out loud. It will tell you your idea is great. What it won't do is give you the hard truth or sit with you through the uncomfortable parts. That kind of nuanced, emotionally intelligent feedback is where growth happens.
The Stakes: Real Growth Needs Friction
Mentoring can change your trajectory this quarter and five years from now. Sure, a model can list steps to negotiate a raise or resolve a conflict. But it can't share the scars from trying, or coach you through the shaky moments before the conversation.
A great mentor will break a tough situation into moves, offer personal strategies, and then push you to act. You take the step, win or learn, and your confidence compounds. That loop is priceless.
Over a year, Maher has seen shy juniors turn into proactive creatives. Some even choose to reroute-switching roles or disciplines-and that's a win too. There's a ripple effect as mentees become mentors. "Reverse mentoring" also shifts perspective: a senior male designer mentoring a younger woman gains insight he wouldn't get from a machine. That builds empathy across the studio.
Use AI as an Assistant, Not a Mentor
Keep AI in your toolbox for prepping, brainstorming, and first drafts. It's a great sparring partner for options and outlines. Just don't confuse quick answers with deep development.
If you want to tighten how you use AI for prep work, explore practical ChatGPT workflows or browse a curated list of popular AI tools. Then get a human mentor to challenge your thinking and keep you honest.
How to Build a Mentoring Culture (Even in a Small Studio)
- Keep it lightweight but consistent. Pair people for a 90-minute chat every 4-6 weeks. Small time, big outcomes.
- Invest in access. If your studio lacks senior mentors, tap external networks or set up coffee chats with trusted industry contacts.
- Mix the pool. Cross-discipline and cross-gender pairings break bubbles. A design lead mentoring a developer (or vice versa) sharpens both.
- Set clear goals and closure. Define success, agree on a timeframe, and set an end point. Review progress, celebrate wins, and decide next steps.
Try This This Month
Pick one mentor (inside or outside your studio) and schedule a 90-minute session. Bring one real challenge and the context behind it-no fluff. Ask for pushback, commit to one action, and book the follow-up on the spot.
Bottom Line
Use AI to prep. Use humans to grow. The magic of mentorship is trust and accountability-someone who's walked the path, cares enough to challenge you, and will ask next month, "Did you do it?" Careers are marathons, not one-click sprints.
Your membership also unlocks:
