Insurance's AI adoption reveals a striking paradox
AI is boosting speed, decision quality and efficiency across insurance. Earnix's early outlook for its Insurance Industry Trends Report 2026 shows AI use is now mainstream, with nearly all surveyed insurers using it somewhere in their workflows. Nearly 80% plan to research or deploy generative AI within two years.
Here's the paradox: investment and adoption are rising, but operational readiness is lagging. Skills, talent and governance aren't keeping pace. Legacy tech and complex processes mean AI isn't "plug and play." Integration takes time, money and people who know what they're doing.
Adoption is up. Maturity isn't.
Only about one in three executives strongly agree they already have the right AI talent in-house. As Earnix's outlook explains: "The competitive advantage will belong not to insurers with the most AI tools, but to those with the clearest, most coherent strategy and the talent to execute it."
That's the line between adoption and maturity. Adoption means you're using AI. Maturity means you have the governance, integration frameworks and skills to use it responsibly, consistently and at scale.
Why this matters now
Immature AI use doesn't just cost you an edge-it creates audit, documentation and regulatory exposure. Weak controls around data lineage, explainability and model monitoring can put you on the wrong side of your auditors and supervisors. Frameworks such as the NIST AI Risk Management Framework are quickly becoming baseline expectations.
What high-maturity looks like
- Clear strategy: Defined business problems, measurable outcomes and a prioritised roadmap.
- Data foundations: Clean, well-governed data with lineage, access controls and monitoring.
- Integrated workflows: Models embedded into rating, underwriting, claims and servicing-not just pilots.
- Model risk management (MRM): Policies for documentation, validation, bias testing, explainability and drift detection.
- Talent mix: Actuaries, underwriters and claims experts upskilled in AI, paired with data scientists and ML engineers.
- Change management: Training, process updates and incentives so front-line teams actually use the tools.
- Value tracking: Live dashboards for lift, loss ratio impact, cycle time and leakage reduction.
90-day action plan
- Inventory your AI: List every model, use case and vendor. Note owners, data sources and decisions affected.
- Pick two high-yield use cases: For example, straight-through processing in claims or next-best-action in retention. Define KPIs and ship improvements.
- Stand up lightweight governance: Cross-functional forum (product, actuarial, risk, IT, legal) to approve use cases and set minimum controls.
- Close immediate skill gaps: Run targeted training for actuaries, underwriters and claims leaders on practical AI and model oversight. See AI courses by job.
- Create a model register: Centralise documentation for purpose, data, features, validation, approvals and monitoring.
- Prep for audits: Standard templates for explainability, bias checks and change logs. No model goes live without them.
- Vendor sanity check: Require transparency on training data, monitoring, and controls. Bake SLAs into contracts.
12-month investments that pay off
- Hiring: MRM lead, ML engineer, data product manager and a QA/validation function.
- Data modernization: Common feature store, data quality SLAs and lineage tooling.
- Integration: API layers to plug models into rating engines, policy admin and claims systems.
- MLOps: Versioning, automated testing, monitoring and rollback for every model.
- Controls: PII minimisation, access governance and encryption-built into pipelines, not bolted on.
- Explainability at the edge: Human-friendly reason codes in underwriting and customer communications.
The outlook's conclusion is blunt: "AI adoption has reached the early majority, but readiness has not." Fix the imbalance-skills, data foundations and governance-and AI stops being experimental. It becomes how you write better risks, settle cleaner claims and move faster than your peers.
Your membership also unlocks:
