InsurTech Funding Is Up. Here's How to Turn It Into Results
Capital is flowing into InsurTech again. More startups, more pilots, more noise. For carriers, brokers, and MGAs, this is both opportunity and risk. The edge goes to teams who can test fast, de-risk vendors, and lock in measurable gains.
Recent events like InsurTech on the Silicon Prairie and ongoing conversations with carrier CIOs point to the same conclusion: AI is moving from slideware to daily workflow. Underwriting, claims, fraud, and distribution are getting real traction-quietly, in the back office first, then at the point of sale.
Where the Money Is Going-and Why It Matters
- Underwriting augmentation: Triage, document extraction, and pre-fill that cuts days down to hours. The goal isn't full automation-it's better decisions with less manual drag.
- Claims acceleration: Severity prediction, subrogation scoring, and straight-through processing on clean segments. Even small lifts compound when volume is high.
- Distribution enablement: Agent co-pilots, smarter quoting, and lead scoring. Faster response = higher bind rates.
- Fraud and SIU: Network analytics and anomaly detection that reduce leakage without spiking false positives.
- Ops productivity: Email classification, intake, and workflow orchestration. Less swivel-chair, more throughput.
Rising funding means faster product cycles and more choices. It also means vendor risk. Treat selection, security, and model governance as core disciplines-not afterthoughts.
A CIO-Level View: Practical AI, Not Theater
At the 2025 InsurTech on the Silicon Prairie conference, leaders from established carriers-like Mutual of Omaha's CIO-kept focus on practical wins. No hype. Just repeatable plays: underwriting assistance, claims triage, and agent productivity tools that fit into existing systems and controls.
The takeaway is simple: pick problems with tight scope, clean data, and clear outcomes. Then instrument everything.
How to Choose an InsurTech Partner Without Getting Burned
- Start with a one-sentence problem. "Reduce small-commercial quote time by 30%." If the vendor can't map features to that outcome, move on.
- Ask for proof on your data. Benchmarks and references help, but nothing beats a 30-60 day pilot with your book.
- Security and compliance, first-class: SOC 2 Type II or ISO 27001. Data residency options. Encryption in transit and at rest. Clear breach processes.
- Data rights in plain English: Who owns outputs? Is your data used to train their general models? What happens on termination?
- Model risk management: Documented features, monitoring, drift alerts, testing for bias and stability. Align with your MRM policy and audit expectations.
- Integration reality check: How do they connect to your core, data lake, or CRM? Pre-built connectors? Webhooks? Batch? No vague "easy integration" claims.
- Business strength: Cash runway, concentration risk, founders' domain experience, and customer logos you can verify.
- ROI math you can defend: Productivity lift, loss ratio impact, quote-to-bind lift, NPS shifts. Ask for a pro forma with assumptions you can test.
Pilot Like a Pro
- Define success upfront: 3-5 metrics max (e.g., handle time, straight-through rate, severity accuracy, quote-to-bind).
- Pick a narrow slice: One LOB, one region, or a clean claim segment.
- Set a 30/60/90 cadence: Week 2 access, week 4 live, week 8 readout, week 12 go/no-go.
- Lock data controls: Sandbox first, least-privilege access, production keys separated, full audit logs.
- Align procurement early: Security review, data processing addendum, model documentation-start these on day one.
Build vs. Buy: Three Simple Rules
- Build where you have proprietary data and differentiation (pricing models, unique underwriting IP).
- Buy for accelerators that don't define your brand (document AI, intake routing, generic copilots).
- Blend by using vendor components with your models on top. Keep data and core logic in your control.
Metrics That Matter (Pick a Few)
- Underwriting: Quote turnaround time, quote-to-bind lift, hit ratio on target segments, premium growth with equal or better loss ratio.
- Claims: Cycle time, touch count, straight-through rate, severity accuracy, leakage reduction, subro recovery per claim.
- Distribution: Lead response time, agent adoption, win rate against top competitors, average premium per submission.
- Ops: Cases per FTE, backlog, first-contact resolution, rework rate.
AI Governance Without the Drag
You don't need a 200-page policy to run AI responsibly. You need a clear standard, audit-ready documentation, and alerts when models drift or degrade. Keep humans in the loop where decisions affect pricing, coverage, or adjudication.
- NIST AI Risk Management Framework for practical control categories.
- NAIC AI Principles for accountability, fairness, and transparency anchors.
What to Do This Quarter
- Pick two initiatives: One revenue (quote speed or bind rate), one cost (claims cycle time or leakage).
- Shortlist three vendors each: Force a bake-off with your data and a fixed pilot timeline.
- Stand up a lightweight MRM process: Intake form, risk tiering, testing checklist, monitoring plan.
- Enable your teams: Train underwriters, adjusters, and distribution staff on practical AI use and limits.
Upskill Your Team
If your organization is moving on AI projects and you want focused training by role, explore curated options here: AI courses by job role. Keep it simple: one course per function, then apply it in a live pilot.
Bottom Line
Funding is rising. Tools are better. The winners will be the teams that keep scope tight, measure hard outcomes, and treat vendor risk like a first-class citizen. Start small, move fast, and scale what works.
Your membership also unlocks:
