So... you want to launch an insurtech
The industry has seen wave after wave of startups. With AI in the mix, that wave looks bigger. Many founders expect a quick win: a product that fixes a painful problem and gets fast traction with carriers and investors. The truth most teams run into? Adoption takes longer, costs more, and demands more proof than expected.
Tim Hardcastle, CEO of INSTANDA, learned this firsthand after launching in 2015. His take is simple: every tech movement rides a surge of hype, a period of letdown, then a steady normalization. Insurtech followed that path. AI is doing the same.
The hype cycle is real - plan for it
Early on, enthusiasm can carry you-demos land meetings, pilots get greenlit, and headlines make it feel like the market is ready. Then procurement, security reviews, and integration realities slow things down. That's not failure; it's the pattern. Build a plan that assumes momentum will cool before it stabilizes.
Translate that into your model. Treat hype as a door opener, not a forecast. Budget for the middle stretch where real adoption is won through proof, patience, and repeatable outcomes.
Adoption takes longer than you think
Carriers and MGAs saw INSTANDA's product as "very cool," but adoption lagged. Expect the same. Enterprise buyers must protect balance sheets, regulatory obligations, and core systems. Your job is to de-risk the choice with evidence.
- Integration: Show reference architectures and clear paths into policy, billing, and claims. Publish APIs and sample mappings.
- Security and compliance: Arrive with a security pack (SOC 2 or ISO baseline, pen test, data flow diagrams, vendor questionnaire ready).
- Actuarial and regulatory: Provide methodology notes, validation data, and filing guidance if you touch rating or forms.
- ROI proof: Replace "efficiency" claims with measurable outcomes (e.g., 18% faster quote-to-bind, 12% loss ratio impact on the target segment).
- Pilot design: Time-boxed, narrow scope, production-like data, success criteria agreed up front.
- Change management: Enable underwriters, claims teams, and distribution with training, job aids, and internal champions.
Funding for a long sales cycle
Long enterprise cycles mean you need more runway than your pitch deck suggests. Underwrite 18-24 months from seed to predictable revenue, more if you're core-adjacent. Stagger milestones around product readiness, early design partners, and the first two reference accounts.
- Price for value and service load. Implementation lift is real-don't bury it.
- Guard gross margin. Services can open doors, but product needs to carry the business.
- Instrument your funnel. Time from intro to signed SOW is the metric to beat.
Hire for enterprise selling, not just product
Great tech won't close complex deals on its own. Bring in people who speak carrier. That means enterprise sellers with payer/provider or carrier backgrounds, solutions engineers who can whiteboard a target architecture, and compliance leaders who preempt objections.
Culture matters more than slogans. As Hardcastle puts it, the founder's behavior sets the standard. Clarity on what the business stands for-and consistent follow-through-becomes the operating system for decisions, hiring, and customer trust.
A few early mistakes to avoid
- Underestimating adoption timelines and cash needs.
- Chasing too many segments at once-pick an ICP and win it.
- Custom work that derails the roadmap.
- Pricing that ignores enterprise support costs.
- Underinvesting in customer success after go-live.
Playbook: from idea to scalable traction
- Problem clarity: One painful, revenue-linked use case. Name the metric you'll move.
- ICP focus: Line of business, company size, tech stack patterns, and buying committee mapped.
- Proof kit: Demo with production-like data, ROI calculator, 2-page business case template, security pack, sample SOW, and an implementation plan.
- Pilot structure: 90-day scope, weekly milestones, conversion plan, and success criteria.
- References: Two credible logos or design partners ready to speak to results.
- Scale plan: Configuration standards, migration playbooks, and partner enablement.
What carriers and MGAs should ask
- Value: Which KPI moves in quarter one? What's the counterfactual?
- Risk: Data use, model governance, and regulatory implications documented?
- Fit: Integration effort quantified with your core and data estate?
- Run: Who owns change management and user adoption? What does "done" look like?
AI will follow the same arc-treat it with discipline
AI is surging into underwriting triage, FNOL, fraud detection, and agent productivity. Expect an initial spike, a pullback, then steady, durable use cases. Build guardrails now-model risk management, bias testing, human-in-the-loop, and secure data handling are table stakes.
For policy guidance and principles many carriers use, see the NAIC's perspective on responsible AI. Read the NAIC AI Principles.
Quick checklist
- 12-24 month runway, not 6-9.
- One ICP, one killer use case.
- Security pack ready on day one.
- Pilot with clear success criteria and a conversion path.
- Price for value and enterprise support.
- Founder sets the tone-clarity, consistency, and visible standards.
Bottom line
Insurtech success isn't about the loudest launch. It's the quiet, consistent work of reducing risk for buyers, proving business value, and building a culture that does what it says. Do that across a few accounts, and the "slow" adoption suddenly looks like momentum.
If you're upskilling your team on practical AI skills for underwriting, claims, and operations, this curated catalog can help: AI courses by job role.
Your membership also unlocks:
