Italy first in EU with sweeping AI law, imposing deepfake prison terms and child safeguards
Italy passes the EU's first comprehensive AI law, bringing criminal penalties, child safeguards, and transparency. Legal teams face tougher oversight, audits, and TDM limits.
Italy enacts first comprehensive EU-wide AI law: what legal teams need to know
Italy has approved a far-reaching law governing artificial intelligence, the first of its kind in the EU. It sets criminal penalties for harmful misuse, restricts child access, tightens transparency and human oversight, and lays out copyright standards for AI-assisted works.
The framework is consistent with the EU AI Act and signals stricter governance across workplaces and regulated sectors. Enforcement sits with the Agency for Digital Italy and the National Cybersecurity Agency, backed by new funding to stimulate compliant AI development.
Criminal exposure and prohibited conduct
- Deepfakes and manipulated content: Illegal distribution that causes harm carries 1-5 years of imprisonment.
- Aggravated use in crimes: Using AI for fraud, identity theft, or related offenses triggers harsher penalties.
- Practical takeaway: Build content provenance, watermarking, and takedown workflows. Document harm assessments and escalation paths.
Transparency and human oversight duties
- Workplaces: Employers must ensure clear disclosure and human-in-the-loop controls where AI influences decisions.
- High-impact sectors: Healthcare, education, justice, and sport face stricter rules, emphasizing auditability and accountability.
- Practical takeaway: Map AI use cases, define decision rights, and implement review checkpoints with audit logs.
Child access restrictions
- Under 14: Parental consent is required to access AI systems.
- Practical takeaway: Add age gating, verified consent flows, and child-specific privacy controls to consumer-facing products.
Copyright and text/data mining
- AI-assisted works: Protected if they result from genuine intellectual effort by a human author.
- Text and data mining (TDM): Permitted only for non-copyrighted content or scientific research by authorized institutions.
- Practical takeaway: Keep records of human contribution in creative workflows. Review TDM pipelines and licenses; restrict crawlers where needed.
Enforcement architecture
- Supervisory bodies: The Agency for Digital Italy and the National Cybersecurity Agency will oversee compliance, guidance, and sanctions.
- Expectations: Policy audits, documentation checks, and incident response scrutiny.
- Practical takeaway: Appoint an AI compliance lead, maintain a system registry, and prepare regulator-ready documentation.
Policy objectives and political context
The government set goals of human-centric, transparent, and safe AI, with privacy and cybersecurity as core principles. Leadership framed an "Italian way" to develop and govern AI within ethical guardrails that prioritize people's rights and needs.
Funding and market signal
The law authorizes up to €1bn via a state-backed venture capital fund to support AI, cybersecurity, and telecommunications. Critics argue the sum is limited compared with investment in the US and China, but it still sends a clear compliance-first market signal.
Implications for counsel and compliance
- Scope assessment: Confirm whether your products, models, or services reach Italian users or institutions. Review jurisdiction and offering mappings.
- Risk classification: Benchmark systems against EU AI Act risk tiers. Apply stricter controls for high-impact use cases.
- Governance: Establish an AI policy, RACI for approvals, and a change-management process. Require model and data cards from vendors.
- Workforce policies: Update employee AI-use rules, disclosure requirements, and escalation procedures. Train frontline reviewers.
- Content controls: Implement provenance (watermarks, hashes), automated detection for deepfakes, and takedown SLAs. Preserve evidence for harm analysis.
- Privacy and child data: Integrate GDPR DPIAs, age verification, and parental consent workflows. Minimize data and set retention limits.
- IP management: Document human authorship in creative outputs. Gate TDM to permissible sources or licensed corpora; track dataset provenance.
- Vendor contracts: Add clauses for transparency, audit rights, incident reporting, security, and IP indemnities. Require compliance with Italian and EU AI rules.
- Incident readiness: Create playbooks for AI-enabled fraud, identity misuse, and harmful content. Test response drills and reporting timelines.
Key references
Next steps
- Stand up an AI register and internal review board within legal/compliance.
- Prioritize audits for high-risk and sectoral use cases (healthcare, education, justice, sport).
- Close gaps in content provenance, child-consent flows, and copyright/TDM controls.
- Brief the board on criminal exposure, enforcement posture, and funding opportunities.
If you are building a training plan for legal and compliance teams working with AI, see curated role-based programs here: Complete AI Training: Courses by Job.
