Pig.dev’s Shift: From Windows Automation to AI Caching
Pig.dev, a startup from Y Combinator’s Winter 2025 batch, initially focused on developing AI agent technology to control Microsoft Windows desktops. However, in May, founder Erik Dunteman announced a pivot away from this concept toward a new product called Muscle Mem. This tool acts as a caching system for AI agents, allowing them to offload repetitive tasks and focus on more complex problems.
Why the Pivot?
Pivots are common for early-stage startups, but Pig.dev’s initial focus addressed a major challenge: enabling AI agents to effectively interact with computers over extended periods. This is essential if AI agents are to become truly useful in professional environments.
Another startup tackling a related issue is Browser Use, a Y Combinator alum. Browser Use converts website buttons and elements into a simplified, text-like format, helping AI agents better interact with web interfaces. Its popularity surged after the Chinese AI agent Manus went viral, relying on this technology.
During a recent Y Combinator podcast, partner Tom Blomfield compared Pig.dev’s original idea to Browser Use, but for Windows desktops. The discussion featured Replit CEO Amjad Massad and YC partner David Lieb, who highlighted that long-term computer use—measured in hours rather than minutes—is still a significant obstacle for AI agents. As reasoning context grows, agent accuracy tends to drop, and costs linked to large language models (LLMs) rise.
Blomfield suggested founders could explore applying Browser Use or Windows automation tech into specific industries. Massad agreed and noted that once these technologies function well, their companies will succeed. However, Pig.dev’s founder decided to move on.
Challenges in the Legacy Automation Space
Dunteman shared that his initial plan was to offer a cloud API product, a common approach for AI tools, but customers didn’t respond well. He then tried marketing it as a developer tool, which also failed to gain traction.
He discovered that clients in legacy app automation preferred paying for ready-made automations rather than development tools. Essentially, they wanted consultants to deliver finished Windows robotic process automations instead of platforms for building those automations.
Dunteman was not interested in one-off projects and preferred creating development tools. This conflict led him to abandon the Windows automation focus and develop Muscle Mem, an AI caching solution inspired by the computer use problem.
The New Direction: Muscle Mem
Muscle Mem allows AI agents to offload repeated tasks to a caching service, freeing them to concentrate on reasoning through new challenges and edge cases. While it approaches the computer use challenge differently, it remains connected to the original goal of improving AI agent efficiency in complex tasks.
Dunteman remains optimistic about the future of AI-driven computer use, referring to it as “the last mile” that still needs solving, but now from the developer tooling perspective.
Other Players in Windows Automation
Microsoft is likely the furthest along in Windows automation tech. Earlier this year, Microsoft introduced computer use capabilities to Copilot Studio, targeting graphical user interfaces like Windows. This technology was released as a research preview.
Additionally, Microsoft recently launched an AI agent tool in Windows 11 to assist users with managing settings, showing continued investment in making AI agents practical for everyday computer use.
What This Means for AI and Development Pros
- AI agents still face significant hurdles with long-duration computer tasks, balancing accuracy and cost.
- Tools like Muscle Mem suggest new approaches by focusing on caching and task offloading rather than direct automation.
- Legacy automation customers often prefer turnkey solutions over developer platforms, influencing product strategies.
- Opportunities remain for startups to apply AI automation and interface simplification within specific industries.
- Microsoft’s ongoing efforts signal that enterprise-level AI desktop automation is a high-priority area.
For those interested in AI automation and productivity tools, exploring the latest courses on AI development and automation can provide practical skills to navigate these emerging technologies. Check out relevant automation courses and AI tool resources to stay ahead.
Your membership also unlocks:
