Two in three consumers worldwide would switch providers if communications fall short of expectations, according to Smart Communications' 2026 Customer Experience Benchmark research released June 16. The study, which surveyed 4,000 consumers across financial services, insurance, healthcare, and government sectors, found that 85% say communications directly shape how they feel about a brand - yet only 52% rate their current communications as good or excellent, a 10-point drop from last year.
The findings signal a growing disconnect between what customers expect and what organizations deliver. For PR and communications professionals, the data underscores how operational communication failures - poorly written messages, broken forms, and opaque AI deployments - are now direct threats to brand reputation and customer retention.
Satisfaction drops as expectations hit record levels
The 85% figure marks an all-time high since the study began. The stakes are consistent across every sector: financial services (85%), insurance (86%), healthcare (86%), and government (87%). But satisfaction is moving in the opposite direction. Only half of insurance customers rate their communications positively, the sharpest decline among the industries surveyed.
Roughly two in five customers across all markets do not consider the communications they receive to be good. The study identifies consistent culprits: poorly written communications, broken form processes, and AI deployed without the transparency or human oversight customers now demand. For teams managing brand voice and stakeholder trust, these failures represent a gap between brand promise and operational reality.
AI skepticism grows, transparency demands rise
Consumer confidence in AI's ability to improve customer experience has fallen to 56%, down 5 points year-on-year. Trust in AI to manage personal data securely dropped 6 points in the same period. Concern about the lack of human control increased by 4% globally, with Baby Boomers registering a 10% surge in a single year.
The perceived value of AI for specific use cases is declining: AI-powered financial advice (44%, down 2%), AI-suggested insurance changes (45%, down 6%), and AI health recommendations (46%, down 8%). Meanwhile, 82% of consumers say companies should disclose when AI is used in interactions, a figure that reaches 88% among Baby Boomers and 90% in markets like Australia.
"What we're seeing here is a transition from digital adoption to digital expectation," said Amy Machado, Research Director at IDC. "Customers are no longer impressed by the presence of AI, they're judging how well it works for them." The generational split is stark: 56-57% of Gen Z and Millennials trust companies to use AI responsibly, compared with just 30% of Boomers - the demographic holding the greatest financial assets today. For communications leaders navigating AI for PR & Communications Courses and strategy decisions, the message is that AI deployment without transparency and human oversight erodes hard-won trust.
Form failures and data disconnects drive churn
Nearly two-thirds of consumers (61%) would end a relationship with a company if the data collection process was too difficult, rising to 69% among Millennials and 66% among Gen Z. Half of consumers say they sometimes or always need to repeat information when switching between channels, even though 86% consider seamless information carry-over at least somewhat important.
The most common reason consumers abandon digital channels and escalate to human agents is "unclear communication," cited by 43% of respondents across all age groups, industries, and geographies. Leigh Segall, CEO of Smart Communications, said: "Consumers are telling us they will switch providers when communications fall short or break down across channels, and they are becoming more selective about how and where they trust AI."
For organizations running large contact center operations, unclear communication driving escalations is a measurable and avoidable cost - one that intersects directly with how AI for Customer Support Courses are training teams to handle these breakdowns. Segall added: "The organizations that succeed will be those that simplify complex interactions, apply AI responsibly and transparently, and create experiences that build trust at every step."
Why this matters for PR and Communications professionals
The research reveals that customer communications failures are not just operational problems - they are reputation problems. When 63% of consumers say they will switch providers over poor communications, every unclear email, broken form, and opaque AI interaction becomes a brand risk. Communications leaders should audit the clarity of customer-facing messages across channels, advocate for transparent AI disclosure policies, and treat form and data-collection friction as a loyalty metric, not an IT issue. The organizations that close the gap between brand promise and operational delivery will retain customers who are increasingly willing to walk away.
Your membership also unlocks:
