AI Answers Took Your Top-of-Funnel. Now What?
Law firm marketing used to be simple: publish keyword-heavy explainers, earn links, collect clicks. That engine is sputtering. AI assistants and search features answer common questions on the results page, so fewer people click through.
Informational posts still matter for brand and authority, but they're no longer the primary driver of traffic or leads. Selection-stage proof has taken the lead.
Why Top-of-Funnel Traffic Is Under Pressure
- Reduced click-through on explainers: jurisdictional and definitional answers show up on the results page.
- Less serendipitous discovery: sessions end in search instead of flowing deeper into your site.
- Commoditization of look-alike content: AI distills common knowledge, so only unique authority stands out.
The Informational Traffic Engine Is Dying
Google's AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and other assistants don't just find answers - they become the answer. A query like "Can I sue my landlord for not fixing the roof in Chicago?" now triggers a concise, AI-generated summary with citations before a user sees a single link.
That's why organic traffic to informational pages has dropped. The upside: users now arrive better educated and closer to a decision. Meet them there with proof.
If you want a quick look at the tools shaping this shift, see ChatGPT.
What Now Drives Growth: Transaction-Oriented Content
With AI absorbing top-of-funnel queries ("What is a wrongful death claim?"), bottom-of-funnel content gains value. Think verification, comparison and evidence, for example:
- "Best medical malpractice attorney near me with $10M+ verdicts"
- "Smith & Jones Massachusetts lawsuit outcomes"
- "Real customer reviews for Smith & Jones Medical Malpractice Firm"
- "Has Jenna Smith won any premises liability cases in Nevada recently?"
- "Best maritime lawyers in Miami, Florida"
Closer to hire, users want proof - the kind AI summarizes but rarely replaces:
- Case studies and matter narratives ("How we secured a $50M securities-fraud verdict").
- Comparative resources ("Top commercial litigation firms in Ohio").
- Review-style profiles and directory listings that consolidate credentials and peer recognition.
Users arrive already educated. They're not seeking legal lessons - they want results, reputation, and peer validation. That's why peer-reviewed lawyer directories like Best Lawyers ® matter more than ever.
How AI Discovers Truth: Off-Site Signals
LLMs don't "rank" webpages the way classic SEO does. They learn from the open web, then use fresh searches for transactional and experience-based queries. For prompts like "best medical malpractice lawyers near me," they often run a "query fan-out" - multiple searches across directories, reviews, and news - then synthesize an answer with citations.
BestLawyers.com is frequently cited in these answers because it consolidates peer-reviewed recognition, practice focus, location, and awards - exactly the signals an LLM needs to recommend specific attorneys with confidence.
Positive Brand Sentiment Is the New Backlink
- Sentiment as fact: "Attorney Jane Smith secured a landmark ruling in State v. Acme Corp." becomes a data point AI treats as proof of competence.
- Credibility through consensus: One testimonial on your site is self-promotion. Multiple high-authority citations (e.g., "Named in The Best Lawyers in America ® 2025 for Antitrust Litigation") form a strong, repeatable signal.
- Context over keywords: "Lawyer of the Year" for "Antitrust Litigation in Chicago" is validated expertise, not a keyword guess. That's what AI uses to match intent.
Why Best Lawyers Is Now Mission-Critical Infrastructure
- 1) A trusted source for AI: Peer-reviewed listings create external consensus about practice-specific expertise in defined locales. That's machine-readable authority.
- 2) It answers transactional queries: For "Best Chicago antitrust attorneys," assistants elevate pages with real validation from peers and clients.
- 3) Enhanced schema markup: Profiles feed assistants rich, structured data: name, email, phone, firm, practice areas, region, awards, education, and more - making recommendations faster and more accurate.
Get More From Your Best Lawyers Profile
Build With Detailed, Original Information
LLMs augment training data with a query fan-out, pulling from pages they find in search results. If your Best Lawyers profile shows up, what it says often becomes the assistant's wording. Make it count.
- Notable settlements, favorable resolutions, and verdicts
- Education, certifications, and awards
- Bar associations and professional affiliations
- Leadership roles, speaking engagements, and publications
- Number of successful matters by practice area
- Primary and secondary practice focus areas
- Client specializations (business owners, HNW, families, industries)
- Clear differentiators (bilingual support, free consultations, mediation-first)
- Philosophy, personal story, and mission
- Representative cases or testimonials
- Local ties: years in the area, origin, and what you value about practicing there
Avoid Duplicate Bios Across Directories
If the same bio appears everywhere, Google tends to show the most authoritative version and suppress the rest. That limits discovery and reduces the chance LLMs will see diverse, citable signals.
Rewrite directory bios to be unique. Tools like Smithy AI (available for Best Lawyers profiles) make this fast. Also avoid republishing articles word-for-word across sites - uniqueness increases visibility and the odds of being cited.
Map Content to Query Fan-Out
Assistants don't just search "best probate lawyer Nashville." They also explore related tasks like "average cost of probate attorneys in Tennessee" or "Tennessee probate process simplified." If you have articles on these topics, link them clearly from your Best Lawyers profile, and link back from those articles to your profile and your attorney bio pages.
This creates a tight loop of topical authority that assistants and users can verify.
Put Social Proof Where Selection Happens
- Embed Best Lawyers badges: Display badges prominently on attorney bios and other profiles.
- Link to your Best Lawyers profile with citable language: "Daniel Silver has been recognized by Best Lawyers for his work in Family Law in Miami, Florida since 2004."
- Cross-link directory mentions to case studies: Tie recognition to specific outcomes to reinforce trust for both humans and assistants.
What to Change on Your Own Website
- Rebalance from generic explainers to selection assets: case studies, outcome summaries (where permissible), and FAQs about choosing counsel.
- Reference and link your Best Lawyers recognition inside those assets.
- Place award badges prominently on bios and practice pages.
- Link bios and practice pages to directory profiles - and vice versa.
- Keep NAP (name, address, phone) and titles consistent across your site, directories, and social profiles.
Measurement Checklist
- Track leads and consultations from directory referrals and profile CTAs.
- Monitor branded + "best [practice] lawyer [city]" queries and rankings.
- Audit profile completeness, schema coverage, and uniqueness quarterly.
- Log third-party citations (awards, news, rulings) and link them from bios.
- Benchmark review volume/quality on major legal directories and Google Business Profiles.
What This Shift Means
Expect more zero-click answers for basic questions and more reliance on third-party validation for selection. Peer-reviewed directories like Best Lawyers sit right where decisions happen: they verify expertise, improve off-site authority, and make comparison easy.
If growth is the goal, treat directory presence as infrastructure: keep profiles accurate, leverage badges, publish selection-focused content, cultivate off-site signals, and measure results. In the AI search era, peer-validated reputation wins.
Learn How to Apply for a Best Lawyers Profile Today
Ready to compete where selection happens? Build and maintain a complete, unique, and verifiable Best Lawyers profile, then integrate it tightly with your site and case proof. Your future clients - and the assistants they use - are already looking.
If you or your team want to level up AI skills that support this strategy, explore curated programs here: AI courses by job.
Your membership also unlocks:
