Reddit Users Discover Six AI Writing Giveaways
AI text is everywhere. Writers are feeling the pressure to keep a human edge, and readers are getting sharper at spotting machine tone. Redditors have been comparing notes, not on single "gotcha" words, but on patterns - rhythms and habits that models slip into because they're trained to sound confident, helpful, and endlessly readable.
None of these tells prove authorship on their own. Detectors are inconsistent, and they've produced false positives for non-native writers. Still, when two or three show up together, suspicion rises fast.
1) "And honestly" as a rhetorical speed bump
Writers use "And honestly?" to pivot with voice. Models use it to simulate intimacy on demand. Deployed once, it's fine. Repeated, it reads like a script trying to feel human.
Fix it: say the thing without the throat-clearing. Replace the filler with an observation, a number, or a direct claim.
2) "No fluff" followed by… fluff
The post promises "no fluff," then delivers a runway of disclaimers and generic tips. This happens when helpfulness gets optimized into length and hedging.
Fix it: match the promise to the structure. If you claim brevity, ship bullets and examples. If nuance is required, don't label it "no fluff."
3) Machine-gunned short sentences
You see staccato lines stacked for drama: "You tried. You learned. You improved." One or two add punch. Ten turn the piece into motivational captioning.
Fix it: vary rhythm. Merge fragments. Use a long sentence, then a short one, then a normal one. Rhythm signals a human ear.
4) Contrast framing: "It's not X, it's Y"
"It's not a setback. It's a setup." Catchy in small doses, clunky in bulk. Models lean on this because it projects certainty without adding detail.
Fix it: keep one contrast max. Follow it with specifics - who, what, where, numbers, mechanisms.
5) Over-signposting every turn
"First, second, finally." "Key takeaway." "In contrast." These are useful for dense logic. When they pop up every few sentences in simple pieces, readers smell automation.
Fix it: cut signposts that restate the obvious. Use subheads for structure. Let paragraphs carry the thread.
6) Engagement prompts without engagement
"Curious what others think." Then silence. It mirrors social growth playbooks and broadcast-style posts that never return to the comments.
Fix it: ask a specific question and reply to responses. Or skip the prompt and end with a strong claim or next step.
The bigger picture: why these tells surface
Models predict the next likely token. That nudges them toward high-frequency phrases, safe transitions, and upbeat framing - polished sameness. Detection is still hard, and even research groups note brittleness and easy bypasses.
For context, OpenAI discontinued its AI text classifier due to low accuracy, and the Stanford HAI AI Index has documented the limitations and false positives of current detectors, especially for non-native writers.
How Redditors cross-check suspicious posts
- Look for clusters of tells rather than one-off quirks.
- Ask for specifics: dates, sources, names, examples. See if the answers get concrete or loop back to platitudes.
- Check for consistency across replies. Human writers adapt; models often recycle the prompt.
Self-audit checklist for writers
- Highlight cliches and repeated transitions. Cut half.
- Replace slogans with facts: numbers, timelines, named examples, quotes.
- Align promise with delivery. If you say "quick," be quick.
- Vary sentence length. Read aloud and mark spots that sound robotic.
- Trim empty signposts. Use subheads to organize, not to babysit.
- If you invite discussion, plan to engage. Otherwise, end with a clear takeaway.
Reality check on detection
None of this is foolproof. A sharp human can use these tics on purpose. A thoughtful model can avoid them with the right prompt. The practical move is to stack signals and pressure-test with questions that force detail. If a post reads like a motivational poster sewn to a style guide, proceed with caution.
Sources and further reading
- Stanford HAI - AI Index (detector limitations)
- OpenAI - Note on discontinuing the AI text classifier
Practical resources for your workflow
Your membership also unlocks:
