UnitedHealth Group's AI Strategy Amid Controversy
UnitedHealth Group (UHG) faces a challenging period as it relies heavily on artificial intelligence (AI) to improve financial performance, despite ongoing controversies. After reporting mixed second-quarter earnings, UHG executives engaged with Wall Street analysts, committing to a thorough review of operations and signaling a willingness to exit Medicare and ACA plans that don't meet profit expectations. Investor confidence has faltered, with shares dropping over 18% since the earnings release on July 29, and Fitch Ratings downgrading UHG’s outlook to “negative” while maintaining a “very strong” financial strength rating.
Fitch analysts highlighted risks such as elevated healthcare utilization and increased acuity in the Medicaid risk pool that may hinder margin recovery. Against this backdrop, UHG leaders emphasized technology and AI as key to turning things around. CEO Andrew Witty stated an intention to accelerate an AI-first approach across the enterprise, aiming to revitalize products and operations.
Driving Efficiency Gains Through AI
Optum Health, a UnitedHealth subsidiary, sees AI as central to its turnaround. Dr. Patrick Conway, CEO of Optum, disclosed that the division’s 2025 earnings fall short by about $6.6 billion compared to UHG’s goals. Beyond raising rates and improving margins, Optum plans to leverage technology integration and AI to boost efficiency. Conway forecasts nearly $1 billion in cost savings by 2026 through these efforts.
Dhivya Suryadevara, CEO of Optum Financial, pointed out that both payers and providers are eager for technology-driven solutions to enhance their operations. In May 2025, Optum launched an AI-powered revenue cycle management (RCM) system that streamlines clinical documentation review, medical coding, and billing through a unified interface. Later this year, the company plans to introduce an AI-based real-time coordination of benefits tool, marking just the beginning of its AI product rollout. Suryadevara expressed optimism about the future, anticipating continued innovation in the quarters ahead.
Legal Challenges Surrounding AI in Claims Processing
While AI offers efficiency benefits, its role in claims handling has sparked lawsuits targeting several insurers, including UnitedHealth. Cigna and Elevance Health are also under scrutiny for their AI applications. For example, a California case alleges Cigna used an AI system called PXDX to deny claims in just 1.2 seconds without adequate physician oversight. Cigna denies these claims, and the case is ongoing in the Eastern District of California.
UnitedHealth faces a class-action lawsuit claiming it uses an algorithm to deny rehabilitation care for seriously ill patients, despite knowledge that the algorithm has a 90% error rate. The suit was filed by Medicare Advantage plan members or their heirs following an investigation by STAT, a health and science news outlet. According to the report, internal documents reveal UnitedHealth managers directed clinical staff to keep rehab stays within 1% of the algorithm’s projected days. UnitedHealth denies these allegations, stating the AI tool serves as a guide for providers rather than a determinant for coverage decisions. A federal judge has allowed some claims to proceed while dismissing others.
For professionals in the insurance industry, these developments underscore the increasing role and risks of AI integration in claims processing and health plan management. Staying informed about AI tools and their regulatory and legal implications is crucial. Those interested in expanding their knowledge of AI applications in insurance may find relevant courses and resources at Complete AI Training.
Your membership also unlocks:
