Human Creativity Triumphs: Vince Gilligan Rejects AI in Apple TV's Pluribus
Vince Gilligan just planted a flag. His new Apple TV series, Pluribus, opens with a blunt disclaimer: "This show was made by humans." In a moment where AI tools are everywhere, that line is both a promise and a challenge.
For working creatives, this isn't just PR. It's positioning. It tells audiences and collaborators what matters: originality, craft, and the human judgment that gives work its edge and its soul.
Why This Human-Created Vision Matters
AI can churn infinite variations. That's different from making art people feel. Gilligan's stance calls out a growing discomfort: if everything is sampled and stitched by machines, what happens to voice, risk, and taste?
He's not dabbling. He's drawing a line so viewers know exactly what they're getting-and so creators can rally around a clear standard.
Apple TV's Pluribus: Built by People, On Purpose
Pluribus marks Gilligan's return to science fiction and reunites him with Rhea Seehorn. The plot centers on an alien invasion, but the subtext is creative independence. The credits don't hedge: this is a human-made project from script to screen.
- Original screenplay written by human writers
- Practical effects and traditional filmmaking techniques
- Authentic performances from human actors
- Zero AI-generated content at any phase of production
The Debate, Unfiltered
Gilligan didn't mince words. He called AI "the world's most expensive and energy-intensive plagiarism machine" and likened AI output to "a cow chewing its cud - an endlessly regurgitated loop of nonsense." Hollywood is still deciding what role, if any, AI should play in writing, acting, and post. Even guilds have drawn boundaries, such as the WGA's AI provisions.
However you feel about tools, the point is clear: authorship and attribution matter. Audiences are paying attention.
Human Creation vs. AI-Generated Output
- Traditional Human Creation: Original vision, emotional authenticity, cultural context, creative risk-taking
- AI-Generated Content: Algorithmic recombination, pattern-based simulation, statistical matching, predictable outputs
Why This Matters for Storytelling's Next Decade
- Preserves unique human perspectives in narrative art
- Maintains employment for creative professionals
- Supports cultural diversity across formats and genres
- Guards against homogenized content
Practical Takeaways for Creatives
- Decide your stance. If you're all-human, say it upfront-in credits, product pages, and press notes. Consistency builds trust.
- Audit your workflow. Define "no-AI zones" (story, character, visual style) and get team and client sign-off.
- Update contracts. Specify where AI is prohibited or permitted, who owns outputs, and how disclosure works.
- Document your process. Behind-the-scenes footage, drafts, call sheets, and shot logs reinforce authorship.
- If you do use AI, disclose it clearly and keep humans in final creative control. Credit your team first.
Pluribus: What to Expect
Rhea Seehorn leads the cast, bringing chemistry fans loved in Better Call Saul. The series is slated for release in December 2025 on Apple TV+. Expect a sci-fi narrative with a meta-message: the process is part of the story.
The Ripple Effect
Gilligan's position will give cover to other creators who want to commit to human-made work-and pressure those who've over-leaned on AI without disclosure. At minimum, it raises the bar for transparency across the industry.
FAQ
Who is Vince Gilligan?
He's the creator behind Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul, known for precise storytelling and character-driven tension.
What makes Pluribus significant?
It publicly rejects AI in production and stamps its credits with "This show was made by humans."
Who stars in Pluribus?
Rhea Seehorn, reuniting with Gilligan after Better Call Saul.
When is it releasing?
December 2025 on Apple TV+.
For Creatives: Choose Your Strategy and Own It
Whether you draw a hard line or set strict usage rules, make it explicit and market it. If you're exploring AI for non-creative admin work or research, do it with intention and keep authorship clear. For curated learning paths by role, see our overview: AI courses by job.
Your membership also unlocks:
