From shortcut to support: GenAI's role in essay-writing for working writers
AI can spit out a clean essay in seconds. That's not the point. The point is deciding where it should help and where it will hurt your thinking.
Here's a simple, evidence-informed way to turn GenAI from a shortcut into a real support system-whether you write solo or lead a team.
1) Use GenAI-on purpose
Ignoring AI doesn't make your writing better. It just makes your process blind. Writers already use it to summarize, generate angles, and tidy prose.
Build basic AI literacy: know what it does well (patterned structure, surface-level synthesis) and what it gets wrong (factual errors, shallow reasoning, generic voice). Use it with intent, not habit.
2) Protect the stages that build your thinking
Certain steps should stay human. Overusing AI there weakens retention, mental mapping, and your ability to connect ideas under pressure.
- Keep human-only: reading source material, interpreting texts, forming original arguments, and writing the final draft.
- Why: these steps train core skills you rely on for every project-structure, judgment, and voice.
3) Set a clear usage plan (for yourself or your team)
"Use AI if you want" creates confusion. "AI is banned" is unrealistic. Define the exact moments AI is allowed and banned.
- Allowed: clarifying a main idea, generating an initial outline, pressure-testing arguments you already formed, spotting gaps, light copy edits.
- Not allowed: replacing the reading, interpreting sources, inventing your core argument, or producing the final draft.
Write this down. Treat it like a style guide. It cuts misuse and speeds decisions.
4) If you manage writers: enforce without accusing
Misuse isn't always malicious-it can be time pressure, low confidence, or unclear rules. Start with curiosity, not blame.
- Ask the writer to narrate how they built a section: sources, notes, decisions.
- Have them explain the ideas in their own words, then rewrite that passage based on the explanation.
- Apply penalties if needed, but use the rewrite to recover authentic voice and clarity.
A simple essay workflow that preserves depth and saves time
- Read and annotate sources yourself. Capture key claims and evidence.
- Draft a one-sentence thesis and 3-5 supporting points-by hand or plain text.
- Use AI to suggest alternative outlines, counterarguments, and missing angles. Keep only what strengthens your thesis.
- Write the first draft yourself. Quote-check as you go.
- Optional: run a copy edit pass with AI for grammar, clarity, and structural suggestions-then accept changes selectively.
- Finalize manually. Confirm citations, tighten transitions, and restore voice.
Risks to watch-and quick fixes
- Generic voice: Keep a personal "voice file" (phrases, syntax, stance). After AI edits, do a final pass to re-insert your tone.
- Shallow logic: Before drafting, list your core claims and evidence. If AI proposes a point, you must be able to defend it without the model.
- Factual errors: Verify names, dates, and quotes against primary sources. Treat AI outputs as suggestions, not facts.
What this gives you
Clear boundaries turn AI into scaffolding, not a crutch. You protect high-value thinking, speed up low-level tasks, and keep your voice intact.
The win isn't faster words-it's stronger ideas with less drag.
Helpful resources
- Curated AI tools for copywriting to test support tools without bloating your stack.
- COPE's position on AI-assisted writing for ethical guardrails that translate well to professional publishing.
Your membership also unlocks:
