AI Overview citations: Why they don't drive clicks (and what to do)
AI Overviews look like prime real estate. They're not. Visibility goes up, clicks don't. Treat them like billboards, not storefronts.
Data from 20,000+ queries shows the top AI Overview citation delivers roughly Position 6 clicks. Great for exposure. Weak for traffic.
What the data shows
The analysis covered more than 20,000 ranking queries across automotive repair, ecommerce, education, fitness, healthcare, manufacturing, and SaaS. A focused case study reviewed 200+ SERPs with AI Overviews from February to April 2025, tracking AI Overview placement, blue-link position, CTR, impressions, and clicks via Google Search Console and Semrush.
- Ranking first in an AI Overview ≈ Position 6 clicks. It's not a golden ticket.
- CTR drops off a cliff inside the Overview. By citation 5, you're practically invisible.
- The Top 3 organic blue links still win on clicks and intent.
Translation: AI Overview visibility doesn't equal traffic. It can support authority and brand recall, but it won't replace blue-link performance.
So, why aren't AI Overviews driving clicks?
On-screen answers satisfy intent
Google is answering informational queries in-line. That's classic zero-click behavior, accelerated by summaries inside AI Overviews.
Brand mentions lack context
Blue links sell the click with titles and meta descriptions. AI Overview citations are tiny and bland. Your brand becomes a footnote.
Position inflation
"First" inside the Overview isn't "first" on the SERP. The top is crowded with ads, site links, map packs, and modules. Users scroll to escape the clutter.
Engagement collapses fast
Citations are small, packed tight, and visually unappealing. Attention decays rapidly. By citation 4 or 5, you're background noise.
What should SEOs do about it?
Reframe goals. Visibility is useful, but clicks and revenue still come from blue links. Here's the plan.
1) Optimize for the Overview, but don't overvalue it
- Identify high-volume FAQs already triggering AI Overviews. Keyword difficulty still matters, but newer domains can win here.
- Place tight "answer capsules" under H2/H3s. Keep answers under 200 characters. Be clear, direct, and citable.
- Don't include external links inside the answer capsule. Don't point search engines away from your best summary.
- Use structured markup where it makes sense, write for natural language queries, and solve real user questions on-page.
If you need context on how AI Overviews work, review Google's documentation: About AI Overviews and web links.
2) Double down on Page 1 blue links
- Content depth: Cover the topic completely. Longer engaged sessions and lower bounce rates follow.
- Link authority: Backlinks still move the needle for both blue links and AI Overviews.
- Technical health: Monitor Core Web Vitals and site performance. Users won't wait. Neither will rankings.
3) Consider tracking assisted conversions
Treat AI Overview citations as upper-funnel assists. They can prime recognition that converts later through another channel.
- Be careful claiming big "direct" spikes from Overview visibility. That's a stretch.
- Expect some lift in branded organic searches. Track branded vs. non-branded, but accept the lines are blurrier.
- Map real user journeys. Present them in a way leadership understands, not just what flatters SEO.
4) Track CTR realistically
Stop benchmarking against fantasy CTRs. Position 1 isn't 40% CTR anymore. Update your models and educate stakeholders.
Ground your reports in your own data and tools. If you need a refresher on measurement, start with the Performance report in GSC: Google Search Console performance.
Practical workflow to execute this week
- Pull keywords with AI Overviews. Flag informational queries where you already rank on Page 1.
- Add 1-3 answer capsules to each target page. Keep summaries crisp and sub-200 characters. Expand below with rich detail.
- Refresh titles and meta descriptions for click intent. Make the blue link irresistible.
- Build 3-5 relevant internal links into each target page. Support topical authority.
- Secure 2-3 quality backlinks to your best-performing posts. Prioritize referring domains over volume.
- Rebaseline CTR expectations by query type and SERP features. Report deltas, not vanity targets.
Bottom line
AI Overviews are visibility, not a traffic engine. Celebrate the mention, but keep your KPIs anchored to the channels that drive clicks and revenue.
Fight for Top 3 blue links. Keep shipping unmistakably human content. Use AI Overview citations as upper-funnel assist-not the centerpiece of your reporting.
Further learning
Your membership also unlocks:
