Customer service scams: Safeguarding your team and customers in the era of AI fraud
AI is baked into daily life in 2025. It plans our days, answers our questions, and summarizes the web. Useful, yes - but scammers see the same opportunity.
Case in point: a traveler hunting for a cruise support number found an AI-suggested line that looked legit. One call later, there was a fraudulent $768 charge. It's a reminder that even savvy people can get burned when trust is outsourced to a machine.
The trend is real. The Federal Trade Commission reported a $12.5 billion increase in consumer losses to fraud throughout 2024, and the Identity Theft Resource Center warns that AI will make it easier for thieves to pressure people into handing over credentials. For support teams, this is now part of the job.
Why AI fraud hits support hardest
Customer service is where urgency and emotion live. People reach out under stress - a missed flight, a billing error, a broken account. That's a soft spot scammers exploit.
Now add AI summaries and chat answers that sometimes surface planted info. Users skip the usual click-and-verify step, and a fake phone number or chatbot can slide in without friction.
How AI tools get twisted into scams
- Planted support numbers in search: Fraudsters post fake hotlines on random sites. AI systems scrape them and present them as answers.
- Overconfident AI summaries: Instead of links, users get a single "final" answer. Less clicking means less verification.
- Lookalike chatbots: Scammers spin up chat interfaces that mimic official support and push for payment or credentials.
- Voice impersonations: Deepfake audio makes a "rep" or "manager" sound real, raising the pressure to act fast.
These attacks don't always rely on a user making a sloppy mistake. They lean on how AI collects and presents information - and how we tend to trust it.
Red flags your agents should catch fast
- Pressure to act immediately: pay now, verify now, or lose access.
- Requests for gift cards, crypto, wire transfers, or peer-to-peer payments.
- Slightly off branding: logo shades, spacing, tone, or grammar that feels "close but not quite."
- Contact details that don't match the official website or in-product help center.
- Chatbots that ask for payment info before resolving the issue or validating identity.
Verification-first: a playbook for support teams
- Anchor to official channels: Never take numbers or links from search snippets. Agents should reference only the company site, help center, or CRM-approved macros.
- Call-back policy: If a customer was contacted proactively, advise them to hang up and call the number listed on your site. Agents should do the same with vendors.
- Payment policy: No payment collection before identity verification and case validation. Gift cards and crypto are never accepted.
- Script the verification step: Ask for case IDs, masked details (last 4 digits), and cross-check in the CRM. Avoid asking for full SSN, full card numbers, or one-time codes from authenticator apps.
- Maintain an approved contact list: Keep a single page in your knowledge base with official numbers, emails, and hours. Update monthly.
- Suspicion triggers escalation: If anything feels off, pause and route to a fraud specialist. No exceptions.
- In-ticket warnings: Add a macro that reminds customers: "We will never request payment via gift cards, crypto, or wire. Always confirm our contact info on our website."
Scripts you can copy and paste
- For questionable numbers: "For your safety, please end that call and reach us at the number listed on our website. I'll stay here and guide you once you're connected."
- For payment pressure: "We don't process payments this way. If someone is asking for gift cards or crypto, it's a scam. Let's secure your account and review next steps."
- For AI summary confusion: "Search summaries can be outdated. Our verified channels are on our site and inside the app. I'll send the direct link now."
If a customer was scammed: quick response checklist
- Secure the account: reset password, revoke sessions, rotate keys/tokens, confirm 2FA.
- Document everything: numbers called, links clicked, what was shared, and timestamps.
- Notify the bank or card issuer immediately and suggest freezing the card or disputing charges.
- Encourage a report to the FTC and local authorities. Provide guides and links.
- Flag the customer profile for follow-up and ongoing monitoring (logins, changes, requests).
- Share indicators of compromise with your fraud or security team for broader blocking.
Reduce exposure across your support touchpoints
- Make your official phone numbers and support URLs impossible to miss on your site and in-product.
- Pin a "How to verify us" article in your help center and agent macros.
- Add a recorded line intro: "We will never ask for gift cards, crypto, or one-time codes."
- Audit your brand voice and visual consistency so fakes stand out more clearly.
- Publish a scam alert page you can update quickly when new schemes appear.
What platforms and regulators are doing
The FTC has announced crackdowns on deceptive AI use, and more proposals are expected as fraud shifts tactics. Search platforms say they're improving vetting, with Google reporting a large drop in related scams after recent changes.
Good progress - but it won't stop every case. Your best move is a verification-first culture: pause, confirm, then proceed.
Where to report and learn more
- ReportFraud.FTC.gov: file a report and get recovery guidance.
- Identity Theft Resource Center: insights on identity risks and consumer education.
Level up your team's AI awareness
AI will stay in your workflow. The win is teaching your team to use it without giving away trust. If you're building internal training for agents and leads, this resource can help:
- AI courses by job function - practical programs for support teams and adjacent roles.
Out-smarting the smart scammers
AI gives scammers reach and confidence. Your edge is process. Keep the focus on official channels, clear scripts, and a hard rule against urgent payments and off-platform requests.
Slow down the moment, verify the source, then act. That simple habit saves customers money, protects your brand, and keeps your queue clean.
Your membership also unlocks:
