GPs and Hospitals Are Turning to AI Scribes: How They Work and What Risks They Bring
Healthcare providers face mounting administrative burdens. AI scribes have emerged as a tool to ease this load, transcribing consultations in real time and creating medical notes for review. However, experts caution about accuracy issues and data security risks that come with these technologies.
How AI Scribes Work
An AI scribe listens to a consultation and converts speech into text, much like a live court reporter. This transcription then forms the basis of the medical note, which the doctor reviews and approves before adding it to the patient’s record.
Clinicians report significant time savings. Typically, writing notes can take 8 to 10 minutes per 15-minute consultation, but AI scribes reduce this to about a minute. Over a shift, this efficiency gain adds up.
Modernising Medical Referral Systems
There’s growing momentum in Australia to replace outdated fax-based medical referrals with digital solutions. Queensland Health is piloting AI scribes in several hospitals, pairing them with integrated electronic medical records (ieMR) systems. This combination improves workflow and supports safer, faster patient care.
Potential Pitfalls of AI Scribes
Despite clear benefits, these tools are not error-proof. AI can struggle with strong accents, background noise, and complex medical terminology. Mistakes such as confusing drug names, misclassifying symptoms, or generating inaccurate content (“hallucinations”) can occur.
Currently, AI scribes are not regulated by the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA). This means legal responsibility for the content falls on the healthcare professional. Vigilance is required to ensure errors don’t slip into patient records.
Privacy and Data Protection Concerns
Patients should be aware that their consultations might be recorded or transcribed by AI. Hallucination rates can range from 0.8% to nearly 4%, potentially leading to harmful errors if not corrected.
Data breaches in healthcare are a growing concern, with sensitive information often targeted by cybercriminals. Effective protection depends on the practices of individual clinics and hospitals, including strong IT security, multi-factor authentication, and transparent privacy policies.
Choosing AI vendors that store data locally, encrypt sensitive information, and do not reuse patient data for AI training without explicit consent is crucial for safeguarding patient privacy.
Key Questions Patients Should Ask
- Will this consultation be recorded or transcribed by AI?
- Who manages my data, and where is it stored?
- Is my information used to train AI or shared with third parties?
- Can I refuse AI transcription and still receive the same quality of care?
Healthcare professionals adopting AI scribes should ensure patients are informed and comfortable with the process, maintaining trust and safety.
For healthcare workers interested in learning more about AI tools and their applications, resources and courses are available at Complete AI Training.
Your membership also unlocks:
