AI Is Rewriting the PM Job: From Builders to Evaluators
Paytm founder and CEO Vijay Shekhar Sharma says product managers are headed for a major shift: "only be evaluators." In his view, AI agents will generate, ship, and iterate. PMs will grade the work, set direction, and keep standards high.
That's not hype. It's the natural result of AI systems drafting specs, wireframes, test cases, and even production code. The question isn't if the role changes-it's how you adapt.
What "Only Evaluators" Actually Means
- PMs set problems, constraints, and success metrics-AI agents produce options.
- PMs review outputs: product flows, copy, designs, experiment plans, and code diffs.
- PMs decide go/no-go, run canaries, and measure real impact against pre-set guardrails.
- PMs own accountability for outcomes, safety, and user trust.
Skills That Rise (and Those You Can Drop)
- Up: problem framing, metric design, evaluation rubrics, experiment design, risk and compliance.
- Up: prompt and agent orchestration, data/ML literacy, cost-performance tradeoffs.
- Up: qualitative judgment-user interviews, insight synthesis, narrative clarity.
- Down: writing PRDs from scratch, manual acceptance testing, hand-built backlog grooming.
The New PM Workflow With AI Agents
- Define the objective, constraints, and KPIs. Be specific and measurable.
- Choose or compose agents (spec, UX, QA, code) and set prompts plus context windows.
- Create an evaluation rubric for functionality, UX clarity, safety, latency, and cost.
- Run offline evals on a benchmark set. Compare agent variants before live traffic.
- Shadow deploy behind feature flags. Add human-in-the-loop review for edge cases.
- Canary to a small cohort. Monitor task success, failure reasons, and incident reports.
- Post-ship: weekly audits, drift checks, and re-evals as data or models change.
Team Design Implications
- Smaller pods: 1 PM, 1 designer, 1-2 engineers, plus shared AI ops support.
- QA shifts into red-teaming and evaluation harnesses, not just manual testing.
- PM pairs closely with data/ML on eval sets, bias checks, and rollback criteria.
- Backlog becomes a queue of problems and metrics; agents generate candidate solutions.
Risks to Watch
- Over-trusting first outputs. Require diverse options and head-to-head tests.
- Bias, privacy, and compliance gaps. Document data sources and approvals.
- Evaluation drift: your rubric gets stale while models change. Schedule re-certification.
- Cost blowouts: track tokens, latency, and GPU minutes per task.
30/60/90 Plan for Product Leaders and PMs
- 30 days: Audit your workflow. Tag tasks agents can handle in specs, tickets, QA, and analytics. Draft evaluation rubrics for your top 3 use cases.
- 60 days: Pilot one feature built by agents end-to-end under a PM evaluation process. Ship behind a flag with canary coverage and a rollback plan.
- 90 days: Standardize playbooks: prompt libraries, eval sets, safety checklists, and incident response. Update role expectations and career paths.
Metrics That Matter
- Task success rate, time-to-decision, and decision quality scores.
- Cost per successful task, latency per user action, and defect escape rate.
- Drift indicators: drop in eval scores vs. baseline, rising override rates by humans.
- User trust signals: complaint volume, false-positive/negative rates, and opt-out rates.
Governance and Standards
Codify what "good" looks like before agents ship work. Build lightweight RFCs, evaluation harnesses, model cards, and approval gates. Treat them as living documents with owners and review cycles.
If you need a reference model for risk controls, see the NIST AI Risk Management Framework.
Career Outlook
The PM role isn't dying. It's moving closer to editor-in-chief: setting standards, curating the best option from many, and owning impact. Judgment, clarity, and ethical decision-making become the edge.
If you're building your skill stack for this shift, explore practical training for PMs at Complete AI Training.
Bottom Line
- AI will build more. PMs will decide better.
- Your advantage is the quality of your prompts, your evaluation system, and your taste.
- Ship faster by tightening feedback loops, not by adding more process.
Your membership also unlocks:
