Modernising the Contact Center for Always-On Service: AI Promises, Human Reality
The push for "always-on" service sounds smart on a slide. In practice, it often means spreading a daytime model across 24 hours and hoping AI will cover the cracks.
That gap shows up fast: customers get a different experience at 1am than they do at 1pm, and agents inherit the emotional spillover. If parity isn't designed in, the promise of 24/7 turns into a trust problem.
Always-On Is a Design Decision, Not a Switch
Many leaders still treat always-on like a binary: on or off. It isn't. It's a series of choices about what customers genuinely need out-of-hours and how you'll deliver it.
Nerys Corfield, Director at Injection Consulting, put it plainly: always-on means "offering customers the same thing at 1am as they would get at 1pm." That's the standard. If you can't meet it, be honest about what you will offer and set expectations clearly.
The Retailer Reality Check
Late one night before Christmas, Nerys called four major UK retailers. Only two offered access to a live advisor, and some didn't have a strong digital path for urgent needs.
The takeaway isn't to call out brands. It's to highlight the cost of inconsistency. When customers can't predict how quickly they'll get help, they over-contact, repeat themselves, and escalate. Costs go up. CSAT goes down.
AI Coverage Isn't Service Parity
AI can extend hours. It can also downgrade the experience if escalation isn't designed well. "Acceptable customer service is always supplemented with a live advisor," Nerys noted. That doesn't make AI a bad bet; it makes design non-negotiable.
Containment is a metric, not a goal. Out-of-hours models need a clean "pivot to live" for emotional, urgent, or complex issues. And if your daytime flows aren't working, extending them overnight just spreads the pain.
The Frontline Feels It First
When always-on is undercooked, agents see it before customers do. Overnight teams often run with thin support, unclear playbooks, and new hires who haven't had enough time to build confidence.
Then comes the morning "hangover": carryover cases, partial bot resolutions, and a messy queue. Forecasting gets harder when containment varies and escalations spike. Burnout becomes a scheduling problem disguised as a design problem.
Why Always-On Pushes Cloud Migration
Modernising isn't just a tech refresh; it's a pressure release. Legacy platforms struggle with resilience, scale, and integration speed-especially under 24/7 expectations.
Steve Blood, VP of Market Intelligence at Five9, summed up why leaders delay with a memorable analogy: "We're going to the dentist… It's good for me. I know I should go, but I don't know what they're going to find." Cost and lack of AI capability are now the top drivers to change. "Doing nothing" is off the table.
The Hidden Cost of Legacy: Lost Visibility
The biggest leak on-prem isn't licensing-it's what you can't see. Cloud-native transcription and LLM features surface real-time insight into sentiment, repeat contacts, and broken journeys.
That matters at 3am. If you don't know where journeys fail, you can't safely deflect, route, or automate without risking outcomes. Personalisation also suffers when integrations are brittle and context can't follow the customer.
AI-First ≠ AI-Only (And Bolt-Ons Can Become a New Legacy)
Adding AI as a string of bolt-ons looks like progress until release cycles, routing rules, and data handoffs start fighting each other. You recreate fragmentation with a shinier label.
Nerys sees teams migrate to CCaaS, then change nothing operationally. Same queues. Same routing. Same outcomes-just more expensive. Architecture and behaviour have to move together.
Leadership Is the Multiplier
Martin Teasdale, Founder of The Team Leader Community, has seen new leaders thrown into the deep end with no real preparation. Extended coverage amplifies that gap.
Overnight teams and hybrid human+AI models need leaders who can coach, triage, and protect wellbeing. As AI handles more process work, the emotional weight lands harder with humans. If team leaders aren't supported, churn becomes your default setting.
A Practical Model for Always-On in 2026
- Start with customer demand, not slogans: Map what actually shows up overnight, how urgent it is, and what "good" looks like. Validate with data.
- Define parity: You don't need identical staffing at 3am, but you do need a consistent path to resolution with a clear escape hatch to a human.
- Pick the right mix: Follow-the-sun BPO, AI-led deflection, or hybrid-chosen by use case, not trend.
- Align CIO + Head of CX early: Budget, security, data, routing, and outcomes live in the same room. Treat this as one plan.
- Implement in phases: Reduce risk, measure impact, then expand. Build trust with proof, not promises.
- Enable leaders and agents: Clear playbooks, microlearning, real-time guidance, and accessible escalation paths-especially overnight.
- Instrument everything: Track containment quality, pivot-to-live speed, repeat contact rate, and resolution parity by hour.
Governance, Security, and Compliance
Security concerns still slow cloud moves, and internal change risk is real. Providers often maintain compliance capabilities individual teams can't replicate, but autonomy lifts the stakes for guardrails.
As more agentic features roll out, policy clarity matters: data retention, redaction, escalation thresholds, and audit trails. Regulators are raising expectations on transparency and risk management-assume scrutiny will increase.
The Real Test Is Acting On It
Always-on isn't won by buying AI or switching platforms. It's won by setting a clear promise, designing parity and escalation into the model, and modernising tech and leadership together.
If you can deliver consistent outcomes at any hour-without burning people or trust-you've done the hard work. If you can't, narrow the promise, fix the journey, and scale what works.
Join the conversation: Connect with 40,000+ peers in our community on LinkedIn.
Level up your team: Explore practical AI training paths for customer support roles at Complete AI Training.
Your membership also unlocks:
