Teachers Union Calls for AI Ban in Elementary Classrooms
The American Federation of Teachers, the second-largest teacher's union in the United States, launched a major campaign Wednesday calling on schools to remove AI systems and devices like iPads from elementary classrooms.
AFT president Randi Weingarten unveiled ten demands at the National Press Club centered on restoring human-led instruction. The union's immediate priority: ban AI systems in elementary school classrooms entirely.
The action points also include prohibiting screens for students in pre-kindergarten through second grade and blocking companion chatbots for anyone under 16-a practice schools have adopted with little oversight.
What the Research Shows
Weingarten told the New York Times she worries about the stakes. "If we don't find a way to call this out from an education perspective, I fear that we will lose a generation of kids," she said. "The work of teaching and learning in the earliest grades should be done without AI."
A year-long study by the Brookings Institution's Center for Universal Education found that AI in education carries significant risk of harm to children's cognitive and social development. The concern grows as more students substitute real-life friendships with AI chatbots.
The Union's Position
Weingarten emphasized the campaign isn't anti-technology. She said she's "not calling for a total ban on AI or a Chromebook bonfire," but for "getting the balance right to harness the benefits of technology while mitigating the harms."
The AFT's success could shape educational policy for millions of students. Tech companies continue pushing schools to adopt new AI systems even as evidence mounts that risks outweigh benefits in early childhood settings.
For educators navigating these decisions, resources like the AI for Education framework and the AI Learning Path for Teachers offer guidance on how to evaluate these tools critically.
Your membership also unlocks:
