Creativity and Commerce: Competing With AI in Media and Marketing
AI didn't replace creative work-it repriced it. Production is cheap and fast now, so the scarce asset is attention. The question isn't "can you make content?" It's "can you make content that earns trust, feels human, and actually lands?"
Ideation vs. Execution: Where Humans Still Win
Creative work splits into two jobs: coming up with the idea and getting it made. AI is a force multiplier on execution-drafting, editing, translating, rendering at near-zero marginal cost. That doesn't erase creativity; it exposes it. Thin ideas look thinner at scale. Strong taste and a clear point of view get louder.
The Attention Bottleneck (and Why "Good Enough" Isn't)
Content volume is exploding, but people still have the same 24 hours. Algorithms filter the junk; competition tightens among what survives. Paradoxically, we get more low-quality slop and more high-performing, high-polish pieces. The baseline keeps rising, so "good enough" stops being defensible.
Why Low-Fi Human Content Often Beats Synthetic Gloss
In real campaigns, simple phone-shot videos often outperform fully AI-generated or overproduced studio work. Not because of tech-because of emotion. Low-fi reads as relatable. Use AI to speed edits, repurpose clips, and translate-but keep the on-camera presence human and honest.
Trust Is Brand Infrastructure
Deepfakes and synthetic influencers raise the stakes, but novelty isn't a moat. What compounds is consistent insight, a recognizable voice, and transparency. People judge content by usefulness, credibility, and whether it aligns with what your brand stands for. If you're clear about intent and keep delivering value, trust accrues.
Personalization Without the Creep
Personalization feels helpful with consent and creepy without it. If customers opt in-preferences, sizes, history-it feels like service. If you "know" things they didn't give you, it feels stalkerish. Treat it like a relationship: be a friend, not a stalker.
- Ask clearly, show benefits, and let people opt out anytime. See the ICO's guidance on consent for direct marketing.
- Use first-party data first; infer less, ask more.
- Personalize copy and offers, not identities and private details.
Distribution: From Keywords to Meaning
We're shifting from keyword-only tactics to meaning-based discovery. Search and answer engines synthesize, summarize, and cite. That pushes you back to fundamentals: authority signals, structured content, clear comparisons, and presence where models "learn"-list articles, community threads, and other reference sources.
- Structure content for easy parsing (FAQs, summaries, comparisons). Google's guidance on helpful, people-first content still applies.
- Win "upstream" placements: get cited in credible lists and community roundups.
- Publish repeatable formats that earn saves, links, and mentions over time.
A Simple Operating System for AI-Era Marketing
- Point of View: Write the one-paragraph thesis for each campaign. If it's fuzzy, don't produce yet.
- Pilot Lo-Fi: Shoot a phone video or draft a raw post. Test tone and hook before scaling.
- AI for Throughput: Use tools to generate variants, edits, captions, and translations. Keep the core idea human-led.
- Package for Meaning: Add structure-key takeaways, comparisons, sources.
- Distribute Intentionally: Seed in communities, pitch list placements, and republish in formats algorithms can parse.
- Iterate on Signal: Double down on what earns trust and time; kill what only earns impressions.
What to Measure (Beyond Views)
- Trust: Saves, shares, repeat visitors, branded search, replies, and references in third-party content.
- Depth: Watch time, scroll depth, average read time, completion rate.
- Fit: Lead quality, sales cycle velocity, retention, expansion.
- Learning: Content that spawns new questions, comments, and user-generated riffs.
2026: Fluency + Taste + POV
AI fluency is baseline. It gives you the first draft and the fast edit. What wins is clarity, discernment, and work that feels distinctly human-paired with machine speed. Tool skill gets you in the game; taste and a strong point of view help you win it.
If you're leveling up your stack and workflow, explore AI for Marketing for practical plays and training.
Your membership also unlocks:
