MGAs Are Gaining Share. AI Is The Lever.
Recent industry signals point in the same direction: MGAs are growing fast and attracting serious capital. A LinkedIn post from Upstage cites McKinsey research showing U.S. MGA premiums nearly doubled from 2020 to 2024, with private equity accelerating its bets on the model.
The edge isn't distribution alone anymore. It's underwriting speed, accuracy, and the ability to operationalize both across the workflow.
Why AI Matters Now
Here's the simple version: AI shortens the path from submission to bind. It improves intake, enriches data, sharpens risk signals, and compresses quoting cycles from weeks to hours in some cases.
- Submission intake: classify, dedupe, and route automatically.
- Data enrichment: pull third-party data, flag missing fields, validate entities.
- Risk assessment: extract features from unstructured docs, surface risk drivers, score against appetite.
- Quoting: pre-fill, sanity-check rates, and generate broker-ready output with clear rationales.
- Feedback loop: tie wins/losses and loss runs back into the model for continuous lift.
The takeaway: advantages show up where AI is embedded into underwriting workflows, not in a one-off tool. That points to demand for specialized platforms and partners who understand insurance-specific processes.
Implications For MGAs, Carriers, And Investors
- MGAs: Embed AI where decisions are made-intake, triage, appetite matching, pricing support, and referral logic. The goal is faster, cleaner submissions and consistent decisions under pressure.
- Carriers: Expect pricing and cycle-time pressure from MGA competitors running tech-forward playbooks. Without comparable capabilities, loss of share in specialty and niche lines is a real risk.
- Investors: Technology-enabled platforms with repeatable distribution and measurable underwriting lift have leverage. Scale comes from workflow integration, not generic automation.
Build An AI-First Underwriting Workflow
- Data foundation: Centralize submissions, broker emails, loss runs, endorsements, and third-party sources. Decide what "good" data looks like.
- Integration: Connect AI to policy admin, rating, CRM, and document stores. No swivel-chair work.
- Decision support: Provide explainable scores, appetite flags, and pre-filled quotes. Keep the underwriter in control.
- Controls: Add governance: versioning, approvals, audit trails, model monitoring, and MRM documentation.
- Metrics: Track time-to-quote, quote-to-bind, hit ratios by segment, loss ratio deltas, and manual touch reduction.
- Talent: Upskill underwriters and ops on prompt craft, review standards, and exception handling. Create a feedback culture.
- Partnerships: Favor vendors who can sit inside your flow and adapt to your guidelines, not ask you to adapt to theirs.
Where The Market Is Heading
MGAs with embedded AI will earn more broker loyalty by saying "yes" faster and "no" earlier. Specialty lines that reward insight and speed will tilt toward those who can operationalize both.
If you provide AI in this segment, the addressable market looks larger as PE capital hunts scalable MGA platforms. If you compete against it without similar tech, expect margin and share pressure.
Practical Next Steps
- Pick one workflow with clear pain (e.g., submission triage) and run a 60-90 day pilot tied to 2-3 KPIs.
- Standardize document intake, metadata, and broker communications before automating everything.
- Set referral rules and guardrails so underwriting judgment stays central.
- Publish a monthly scorecard: cycle time, touch count, win rate, and loss ratio signals.
If you want a quick way to upskill teams on AI fundamentals for underwriting and ops, explore practical programs here: Complete AI Training - Courses by Job.
Bottom line: The winners won't be the ones with the most tools. They'll be the ones who wire AI directly into how business gets underwritten and bound.
Your membership also unlocks:
