Only 3% of U.S. Households Pay for AI-But That's Changing Fast
Kirby Plessas pays $40 a month for two AI subscriptions. She uses them to plan parties, adjust recipes, and troubleshoot appliances. She's also considering adding a third.
She's an outlier. Only about 3% of American households subscribe to AI services, according to the most recent data from the Bank of America Institute, which tracks consumer spending patterns.
That small number is growing quickly, though. Roughly 10% more households paid for AI in February compared to a year earlier.
The pattern mirrors what happened with streaming services, according to Sekoul Krastev, cofounder of the Decision Lab, a behavioral science research firm. "Once that status quo is created, subscriptions will definitely start to go up sharply," he said.
Free Versions Come With Limits
Most AI platforms offer free access, but with restrictions. OpenAI's default ChatGPT model allows 10 messages every five hours before downgrading to a weaker version.
Pam Dean, who subscribes to both ChatGPT and Claude, remembers hitting those limits. "You're stuck in the middle of something and then you couldn't continue," she said.
A ChatGPT Plus subscription costs $20 monthly and allows up to 1,280 messages daily. Subscribers also access more advanced models and can create customized versions for specific tasks.
Jim Arnold built "Francisco," a ChatGPT tutor that corrects his Spanish and speaks at a pace he can follow. He paid for the subscription without testing the free version first.
About 51% of Americans use AI to research topics they're curious about, according to a Quinnipiac poll from March. They're mostly using free versions.
The Subscription Question: Will Free Always Exist?
OpenAI has about 50 million subscribers. Nick Turley, head of ChatGPT at OpenAI, believes the company could quadruple that number.
Turley said OpenAI will likely keep the current version of ChatGPT free. The company introduced subscriptions not primarily for revenue, but to manage demand on expensive computing infrastructure.
"We weren't even trying to make money," Turley said. "But it's been a really nice side effect that that also generates revenue and builds an amazing business."
The next generation of AI may be different. OpenAI is developing agentic AI-software that acts independently to complete tasks like planning vacations or handling shopping. Turley said such advanced systems could be so expensive to run that they might require payment.
"If we do our job right, many people are going to want to pay and subscribe," he said.
Ads or Subscriptions: The Business Model Question
AI companies could follow social media's playbook and fund services through advertising. But Jeff Hancock, head of Stanford University's Tech and Impact Policy Center, sees problems with that approach.
"People hate it," Hancock said of ads. Social media companies optimize for screen time, which has raised concerns about mental health and attention spans.
AI assistants designed to work in the background would give users less screen time-the opposite of what an ad-supported model needs. "AI platforms have the potential to create a completely different economic model by the incentive being: Is this useful for you?" Hancock said.
OpenAI began testing ads for free users in February. Sarah Womer, who rotates subscriptions across different AI platforms, worries companies could skew results to favor advertisers. She switched to Kagi, a subscription service that emphasizes privacy and blocks ads, when researching products.
Other Models on the Table
The revenue structure for AI is still unsettled. Sam Altman, OpenAI's CEO, suggested at a BlackRock summit in March that AI could be priced like electricity-billed based on usage.
Bundling offers another path. Greg Portell, lead partner at Kearney consulting, believes companies will add AI to existing subscriptions like Amazon Prime or internet service rather than asking consumers to pay separately.
"Every consumer says they have too many subscriptions, but yet every subscription provider is looking at how they can bundle things," Portell said.
Some Americans already access paid AI through work. Corporate accounts often restrict personal use, but Portell wonders if employers will eventually lift those limits as an employee benefit.
For now, most people are content with free AI. Whether that changes depends on how useful the paid versions become-and whether companies can find a business model that doesn't annoy users in the process.
Your membership also unlocks:
