New York City principals have been ordered to pause purchases of any new education technology software until later this summer, as the nation's largest school system struggles to develop an AI policy amid mounting parent concerns. The directive, sent Monday by Chancellor Kamar Samuels, puts a freeze on new tools until the department releases "updated guidance" on artificial intelligence and screen use for the coming school year.
"We know that we must prepare our children to thrive in a world increasingly shaped by new technology," Samuels wrote. "We also recognize the need to consistently provide a safe, developmentally appropriate system with robust transparency and oversight."
A draft policy under fire
The pause is the latest sign of the education department's difficulty crafting a coherent AI for Education strategy. In March, officials released draft guidance that outlined a "traffic light approach." It barred educators from using AI for decisions on grades, promotions, discipline, and counseling, but permitted some uses for family communications and lesson planning. The guidance was vague on how students should use AI, saying only that educators should use "caution" for research and projects.
Thousands of parents have called for a moratorium on artificial intelligence in schools, citing risks to cognitive development, privacy, and the environment. Kelly Clancy, founder of Parents for AI Caution in Educational Spaces, criticized the draft guidance for failing to address what she sees as fundamental harms. "There are huge cognitive and developmental problems with offloading your thinking to AI," she said.
Shifting union stance and broader tech backlash
The unease extends beyond parent groups. In May, American Federation of Teachers president Randi Weingarten called for a ban on AI in elementary schools and no chatbots for children under 16. She also pushed for a screen ban in pre-K through second grade. The speech marked a shift for the powerful union, which last year opened an AI training center in Lower Manhattan in partnership with Microsoft, OpenAI, and Anthropic.
Growing pessimism about technology's impact on student learning and mental health has fueled lawsuits against social media and educational technology companies over addictive algorithms and data privacy breaches. Many parents are now pressing for far fewer screens in classrooms.
Reconsidering the approach
Samuels has acknowledged that the initial guidance was largely a product of plans set in motion by the Adams administration. "We are now working to develop a longer term, more robust policy based on our spring public feedback process," he wrote to principals this week. Education department spokesperson Nicole Brownstein said the purchasing pause is necessary "to ensure proper protocols are in place" regarding safety and privacy.
Why this matters for educators
The freeze on new software purchases signals that districts are reassessing the role of AI in classrooms, and the final policy could bring significant restrictions. Teachers and school leaders should prepare for tighter guardrails around student AI use and screen time. At the same time, building AI literacy remains essential for navigating these changes. Educators seeking to understand responsible AI integration can explore an AI Learning Path for Teachers that focuses on practical, developmentally appropriate strategies.
Your membership also unlocks:
