Pope's New Encyclical Warns Educators: AI Threatens Student Curiosity and Critical Thinking
Pope Leo XIV has issued a direct challenge to educators in his first encyclical, arguing that artificial intelligence and digital media are eroding the conditions necessary for genuine learning. The document, Magnifica Humanitas, released May 25, identifies a fundamental problem: students can now obtain answers instantly, which risks destroying the desire to ask questions in the first place.
"The speed and ease with which answers or summaries can be obtained risk extinguishing the desire to ask questions, which is a process that bears fruit only over time," the pope writes. He calls for schools to teach students when and why not to use AI-a shift from simply teaching how to use it.
The Immediacy Problem
The encyclical identifies a specific threat: digital media fosters "a culture of immediacy and hyper-stimulation, which gives rise to fatigue, boredom, and apathy concerning the effort required for seeking the truth." Education, by contrast, "is a long journey requiring patience and therefore needs time for development and for engagement with reality beyond appearances."
The pope references Plato's Seventh Letter from 353 B.C. to argue that the deepest realities require sustained effort over time-a principle that contradicts how AI systems deliver instant summaries and answers.
Device Exposure and Child Development
Leo XIV warns that early and unsupervised access to digital devices damages sleep, attention, and emotional regulation in young people. He specifically names risks: isolation, bullying, cyberbullying, pressure to share intimate images, and exposure to violent or pornographic content.
The pope acknowledges that parents cannot solve this alone. Tech platforms use business models that monetize attention and time, creating pressure that individual families cannot resist. He calls for "an alliance among policymakers, educational institutions, and families" to establish protective policies.
He points to legislative efforts in Australia, France, and Spain as models, urging governments to set age limits for device use, hold service providers accountable rather than placing the burden solely on families, and establish protections against online sexual exploitation.
Schools Must Rethink Everything
The encyclical identifies a deeper challenge: educational systems designed for a previous era cannot keep pace with technological change. Curricula, school spaces, assessment methods, and the role of the teacher all require rethinking.
Teachers need ongoing training throughout their careers to engage with new technologies critically. The goal is not to embrace AI uncritically but to help students "use them responsibly, critically, and creatively rather than passively succumbing to their influence."
Without careful attention, the pope warns, education risks becoming "an incessant flow of information" that replaces actual research, reflection, and discernment. Fragmented knowledge makes it harder for students to grasp reality as a whole or ask profound questions about meaning.
What Schools Should Actually Provide
Leo XIV proposes that schools offer what the digital sphere cannot: "a shared time for learning and developing trustworthy relationships." He advocates for educational rhythms that include silence, in-depth study, reading, and careful analysis.
The broader goal involves teaching students about sobriety and limits, recognizing the rights of others and future generations, freedom paired with responsibility, and a sense of the common good. These principles translate into concrete educational goals that no AI system can replace.
For educators, the encyclical reframes the challenge: the task is not to keep up with digital tools but to defend the conditions under which genuine learning occurs.
AI for Education resources and AI Learning Path for Teachers can help educators develop strategies for critical technology use in the classroom.
Your membership also unlocks:
