Trust, Not AI Access, Determines Whether Organizations Gain Productivity From AI
Workforce trust will determine whether AI adoption delivers productivity and retention gains, according to a study by The Adecco Group. Only 36% of business leaders say their talent strategy clearly demonstrates AI will create opportunities for workers rather than replace them.
The gap between AI adoption speed and organizational trust is widening. Denis Machuel, CEO of The Adecco Group, said: "AI may move at software speed, but organizational trust moves at human speed. Companies that ignore that gap will struggle to turn pilots into performance."
What builds workforce trust
Executives ranked modeling ethical leadership as the most important trust-building factor, followed by improving decision-making transparency. Tools for employees to measure their impact, role-impact education, and cross-functional collaboration tied for third.
Most organizations are not delivering on these principles. Only 40% of leaders have clearly communicated how AI affects employees' roles, and only 44% believe employees understand how their work contributes to organizational purpose.
Organizations that measure trust outperform peers
The performance gap is substantial. Among organizations that measure workforce trust, 51% report success on staff well-being and mental health, compared to 33% that do not measure trust.
The gap widens on AI outcomes. On AI implementation, 48% of trust-measuring organizations report success versus 29% of others. On talent attraction and retention, it's 47% versus 34%. About half (49%) of trust-measuring organizations hold leaders accountable for how AI decisions affect people, against 33% of those that do not.
Adoption outpaces readiness
Forty-five percent of business leaders expect AI agents integrated into workflows within 12 months. Only 30% of non-line managers agree.
Just 31% of leaders said their leadership team has sufficient AI skills to understand risks and opportunities. Only 22% are highly confident their organizations are developing the necessary digital and future-ready capabilities.
Forty-two percent of organizations are piloting upskilling measures, and 39% involve employees in job redesign.
Future-ready organizations focus on trust
Only 6% of organizations are classified as future-ready, down from 10% the previous year. Nearly half (49%) of that group take a mature approach to measuring trust, compared to 19% of other organizations.
Seventy-six percent of future-ready organizations describe their workforce as highly adaptable, against 42% overall. Seventy-eight percent use AI or analytics to identify which tasks suit humans versus machines. In these organizations, leadership roles are being redesigned to balance human and AI decision-making.
Six ways to build workforce trust
Invest in senior leadership credibility and communication. The Conference Board of Canada identifies confidence in senior organizational leadership as the most influential driver of employee engagement. About seven in 10 Canadian employees are disengaged, and alignment of middle managers with senior leaders is essential to closing the gap.
Close the formal training gap. Over 2 in 5 (43%) of Canadian workers report receiving no skills training in the past year, according to the Future Skills Centre. This is a central barrier to workforce adaptability.
Pair AI deployment with employer-led training. Only 34% of Canadians using AI at work have received training from their employer, and only 27% have received substantial guidance. Both figures lag far behind the pace of AI adoption itself.
Move on workplace technology rather than letting workers fall behind. Nearly half (47%) of Canadian workers say their workplace has been too slow to adapt to new information or computer technologies, up from 39% in 2023. Fifty percent say they have not received enough training to take advantage of these tools, up from 33% in 2023, according to the Diversity Institute at Toronto Metropolitan University.
Build formal mental health and well-being programs. The Conference Board of Canada estimates that effective treatment of depression and anxiety among employed Canadians could add up to $49.6 billion to the economy annually. Forty-five percent of Canadian organizations have put a formal mental-health strategy in place in the past three years, up from 27% pre-pandemic.
Commit to lifelong learning pathways. The C.D. Howe Institute finds that Canada stands below top-performing countries in skills development and has no comprehensive approach to lifelong learning. Long-term unemployed and low-income, low-educated workers slip between the cracks of federal and provincial programs - a gap employers can help close by extending training to roles where the private return is lower but the social and retention return is high.
What this means for HR leaders
HR professionals need to embed trust measurement into leadership accountability systems. The data shows organizations that do this consistently outperform peers on core HR metrics and AI outcomes.
For HR leaders managing AI adoption, AI for CHROs (Chief Human Resources Officers) and AI for HR Managers provide practical frameworks for translating AI adoption into sustained productivity while maintaining workforce confidence.
Your membership also unlocks:
