Showing up to AI agents isn't enough. Marketers must focus on what comes next.
Brands face a familiar problem as agentic AI reshapes how consumers discover products. They must first ensure their offerings appear to the AI agents that increasingly handle search, selection, and negotiation on behalf of shoppers. But getting noticed is only the opening move.
The principle is straightforward: once you've shown up alongside competitors who have done the same, doing more of what got you there won't secure victory. An actor who reaches an audition has already beaten those who didn't-but now faces a different contest entirely against the other candidates in the room.
Brands have always competed for mental presence. Early advertising muscled through via bus sides, posters, newspapers, and television. But when rivals matched that investment, throwing more money at media stopped working. High street banks learned this the hard way, drilling "listening bank" messaging into audiences while their actual branches remained slow and indifferent. Mental presence without product reality failed.
Search engines introduced a new mechanism but kept the principle intact. Brands needed high rankings, but some overinvested in the mechanics of appearing-prioritizing social media reviews over the service that would earn repeat visits.
The immediate task: Be discoverable
Agentic AI presents the same challenge. Marketers should prioritize making brands discoverable to these agents in the near term. The disadvantage of not showing up is real, though it varies by category-more critical for insurance than for cola.
Consulting firms offer practical guidance. Bain & Company recommends chunking evidence-based claims into simple statements that machines can easily read and summarize, while investing more in community engagement since agents weight third-party content heavily. McKinsey's 2025 research on "agent discoverability" suggests brands get involved earlier in the consumption process by aligning with agents' ability to infer need from consumer inputs like diary entries.
Visibility to agents is not a one-time fix. It's a continuum that will shift as the technology evolves.
The harder work: Building lasting preference
Yet staying focused solely on agent visibility will eventually undermine competitive advantage. Securing the first transaction matters, but ensuring the kind of delight that brings customers back requires different work entirely.
Agents operate on logic and language. They evaluate what gets captured in text. They cannot perceive what actually builds lasting relationships: beautiful visualization, elegant design, multisensory and emotional experiences. These qualities live in the fuzzier territory that machines cannot reach.
Marketers must also work backward from their understanding of consumer needs, desires, and contradictions to innovate new products and services. Without that foundation, there's nothing for agents to discover in the first place.
The fundamentals remain unchanged
Agentic AI will be worth more than $3 trillion globally by 2030 according to McKinsey. No marketer can ignore a commerce channel of that scale.
But the underlying rules haven't shifted. A brand must still crystallize difference, consistency, quality, and trust. The final arbiters remain people, not algorithms.
Put in the work to achieve agent recognition. But then ensure your brand has what it takes to edge past the rivals who also showed up. That's where the marketer's real job begins.
Learn more about AI for Marketing or explore an AI Learning Path for Marketing Managers to develop the skills needed for this evolving landscape.
Your membership also unlocks:
